StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Argument Analysis/Critical Response Paper - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The gist of this article is the proposal made by the governor of Michigan State, Mr. Rick Snyder, to fix the problems of Detroit city with…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Argument Analysis/Critical Response Paper
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Argument Analysis/Critical Response Paper"

full The Opinion Page /Editorial (Critical response paper) 07 February Detroits Immigration Solution The article chosen for this paper was written by the Editorial Board of the New York Times (NYT) and published last February 05, 2014. The gist of this article is the proposal made by the governor of Michigan State, Mr. Rick Snyder, to fix the problems of Detroit city with special visa program to attract smart immigrants and thereby re-populate the city of Detroit. It is unusual in the sense that federal immigration policy is a very contentious issue today.

His proposal is to grant these special visas only to certain qualified immigrants such as those with advanced degrees or exceptional abilities in the arts, sciences, and business. Detroit is a major manufacturing city, the home of the Big Three in the auto making industry and yet went bust due to global economic trends, fierce foreign competition through imports, and gross mismanagement. However, Gov. Synders proposal attracted attention because it is not a usual solution but something that is quite creative (NYT Editorial Board, para. 4).The title of the article is quite catchy, as it encourages the reader to read through all of it instead of just skimming because it piques the interest in terms of probable suggestions or solutions to a big problem like Detroit.

Its problem is multi-faceted and the immigration as suggested solution is a bit shallow at best. Even the editorial board admits this solution has a lot of holes in it which will not hold up to any intelligent debate. For one, it is discriminatory in the sense it grants visas to highly-skilled immigrants only although America as a country is built on the labor of everybody, including the nannies, fruit pickers, and blue-collar workers. A suggestion like this is bound to create more problems because the special visa is specific to one site only, in this case Detroit, and restricts the freedom of movement and abode.

However, as people like to say, unusual situations require unusual approaches. This is a clear case of thinking something out of the box because Detroit is now just a ghost city, so to speak. Its industries had been hollowed out by intense foreign competition and propensity of American businesses to outsource high-paying jobs to lower-paying countries elsewhere. It seems nothing worked before, so this proposal came along to revitalize an important city that used to symbolize the industrial might of America.

Giving special visas is bound to anger the many Americans who are left jobless by the economic recession from the collapse of housing market from the speculative bubble, but then these immigrants should be enticed to America because that was how America became great in the past by being the worlds melting pot.Extraordinary problems require extraordinary solutions but it seems this is not one of those situations in which a selective immigration policy is best suited for. Immigration brings with it additional unforeseen problems if done on intention instead of just letting the people choose do so on their free will or own volition; it should not be something that is forced.

It is not a guarantee it will solve the main problem in the first place because what is at issue is the lost competitiveness of American industry due to mismanagement at the top. But then again, as the old adage goes, if nothing works, then try anything. This is the hope a different approach of tackling a problem as massive as the bankrupt Detroit will work. The details of this plan should be studied further although the article did not cite figures or the statistics needed to back up this suggestion.

Additionally, all stakeholders should be consulted to earn the support of the business sector, labor unions, legislators, and the American public. A very effective rhetorical move by the editorial board is the last sentence in their article which states the good news: just such a plan had already passed in the Senate last June. This seems a very surprising turn of the discussion and renders whatever objections a reader may have had moot and academic but this had been done before; Toronto did it successfully decades ago.

Work CitedEditorial Board. “Detroits Immigration Solution.” The New York Times. 05 Feb. 2014. Web. 07 Feb. 2014. .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Argument Analysis/Critical Response Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1627635-argument-analysiscritical-response-paper
(Argument Analysis/Critical Response Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/english/1627635-argument-analysiscritical-response-paper.
“Argument Analysis/Critical Response Paper Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1627635-argument-analysiscritical-response-paper.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Argument Analysis/Critical Response Paper

Victims and Crime: Role of Prosecutor, Defense Attorney, Criminal and Victim

The author states that justice is for everybody.... That is why the prosecutor, defense attorney, criminal and victim rely on sentencing which is formulated based on the law.... It is also important to consider remarkably the victim's rights so as to come up with fair treatment.... nbsp;… Sentencing remarkably has goals associated with each of these roles....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

Background to the Study

They question the real fundamentals behind these critical issues.... In risk analysis, it is realized that some individuals are more risk averse than others.... Current Controversy The core of the argument in this case is the fact that losses have a relatively greater impact on choices than gains....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Boston Marathon Bombing

Boston Marathon Bombing Abstract This paper intends to quantify the different aspects of the Boston marathon bombing and its high amount of impacts that caused disastrous effects.... In addition, the paper will reflect upon the broad aspects associated with the criminal Justice class policies in the American Society, which is concurrent to the Boston marathon bombing that took place in the Boylston Street, Boston, Massachusetts.... hellip; In relation to this context, the paper will comprise a brief overview of the subject matter along with its rationale....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

The Decision to Drop the Atomic Bomb on Japan

For such purpose, this paper will specifically attempt to identify and compare arguments of both sides of this decision that will enable the reader to acquire a more critical position on the issue.... In response to criticism, US President Truman specified that dropping of the atomic bomb However, recent studiesi related to this issue have indicated conflicting and contrasting results involving exaggeration of the number of lives saved by such decision, and the unreal reason and factor of dropping the bomb on two cities of Japan....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

UK Economy Emerges from Recession

This paper will therefore attempt to argue that currently America is going through a depression and not the recession as macroeconomic variables are showing same signs as they were during the depression of 1930s.... The recession also results What is critical however is the assumption that governments, in this type of situation, tend to adapt expansionary macroeconomic policies in order to stimulate growth and increase in employment level....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Realist Approach to Foreign Policy in Syria

This paper therefore seeks to analyze the realist approach to foreign policy in Syria; what do/would Hans Morgenthau and John Mearsheimer says about that; how they would interpret it; and why.... Further the paper will give a brief conclusion on the subject issue – foreign policy.... In the Middle East, Syria as a country has been a critical power in maintaining a balance.... These two opposing sides seeks argue their sides based on their observations and analysis of the foreign policy in Syria....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Extent to Which Victims of Domestic Violence Get Protection from the Criminal System

The paper "The Extent to Which Victims of Domestic Violence Get Protection from the Criminal System" highlights that in most cases, the violence is geared towards women by their male counterparts as they are regarded less energetic than men and therefore cannot resist the violence.... The paper thus reviews the extent to which victims of domestic violence get protection from the criminal system.... This makes it a barrier to the women empowerment, bearing consequences to women's health, strength and even their activities The article on police response to domestic violence victims contains new and significant information relevant in addressing and justifying the publication....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

The Community in a Gated Residential Estate

The author of the current paper "The Community in a Gated Residential Estate" is aimed at assisting us to understand the lifestyles, way of living as well as forms among the gated estates as there is information asymmetry in respect to these.... Macquarie Links's research on gated estates forms the main premise to which the paper pivots.... However, ethnography is at loggerhead with the argument inability of community formation in urban as it has found that peaceful neighborhoods between the urban and community....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us