StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Impacts of Groupthink on Decision Making - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the paper "Impacts of Groupthink on Decision Making" will begin with the statement that modern organizations promote teamwork in their business settings for enhancing information sharing and problem-solving through departmental integration…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Impacts of Groupthink on Decision Making
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Impacts of Groupthink on Decision Making"

It heeds little attention to distinctive ideas and experts’ advice. At this juncture, the role of a project manager is crucial in leading the group to yield the best outcome. This paper will discuss the major impacts of groupthink on decision-making and five major tactics that a project manager can put forth to evade this threat.

Illusion of invulnerability

As mentioned in the introduction, groups that experience groupthink presumably seek little advice from external sources or experts. It normally happens due to their illusion of infallibility or stereotypical nature. To avoid these threats, it is advisable to ‘invite different perspectives’ into the decision-making process (Thompson, 2006, 177). The author also points out that the absence of different perspectives has been the major cause of several corporate or governmental failures in history (Thompson).  

Getting intimidated

The bigger the team the higher the chance to be vulnerable to groupthink. Therefore, the project manager should frequently monitor the size of the team so that it would ensure the spontaneous participation of all members. In addition, to get rid of members’ fear, the ‘risk technique’ could be implemented. As Thompson describes this technique involves several methods; firstly, members will discuss the risks associated with taking a particular decision and further move to propose strategies to meet that possible challenge. Another tactic is to appoint ‘devil advocates to invoke the real opinion of the group members in a way that would avert members' fear (Thompson).

Pressure of uniformity

This is another identified symptom of groupthink. In a group that gives higher importance to uniformity, diversity of opinion is less expected. Subsequently, members tend to suppress their perspectives with the intent to preserve group cohesion. It will deteriorate the quality of the decision as the group is less likely to consider various dimensions of the issue addressed. A leader who would stand impartial might be apt to this situation. In addition, the decision can be delayed by keeping the meeting for another occasion. As per this tactic, “teams may be given guidelines that emphasize continued solicitations of solutions, protection of individuals from criticism, keeping the discussion problem-centered, and listing all solutions before evaluating them” (Maier, 1952 cited in Thompson, 2006, p. 176-77).

Over-dependence on the leader

Members of a group sometimes tend to rely on the abilities of its leader. This over-dependence later gives way to their frustration as the leader would not meet the expected levels of performance in the overall task. This is also one of the negative outcomes of groupthink which can be avoided only by promoting the full-fledged efforts of every member. To ensure active participation, the manager should confirm the size and structure of the group while assigning tasks. Once the group is identified for its passive response to the assigned task, it can be asked for finding “a second solution or decision recommendation as an alternative to their first choices” (Thompson, 2006, p. 179). The process can be intensified further by using time pressure on members to decide by solving the problems assigned to each member.  This tactic would certainly invoke the attention of every member.

Absence of a contingency plan

A team affected by groupthink will not have a strategy to vie with the contingency of any sort. As Spangle and Isenhart (2003, p. 289) point out, disasters like the Challenger space shuttle or the Hubble telescope are some examples of the harmful consequences of groupthink. It happens as the members find themselves less responsible for decision-making other than relying on the unanimity of the group. To improve responsibility, managers can initiate a face-saving mechanism because as Thompson (2006) believes, small teams with organizational support and expectation are more likely to yield good results as they are concerned about failure or poor performance (p. 176). Therefore, the face-saving situation will force members to heed their genuine effort in decision-making processes.

Conclusion

Groupthink is the essential feature of every stereotypical system in which individuals exert force upon each other to think and respond the same way. As it does not encourage different thinking, the decisions made would be comparatively poor in quality or disastrous. There are several techniques that a manager can apply to avoid the threat of groupthink. Among them, inviting different perspectives, risk techniques, delayed decisions, appointing a devil’s advocate, and face-saving techniques are important. However, which of the above techniques is apt to the context depends on the project manager’s discretion.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Decision Making Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1407236-decision-making
(Decision Making Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1407236-decision-making.
“Decision Making Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1407236-decision-making.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Impacts of Groupthink on Decision Making

The Threat of Groupthink

The group decision making can be regarded as a participatory approach in which individuals critically analyze the problem and put forth their opinions concerning the issue.... In contrast, there are numerous pitfalls that affect a team in its decision making.... Week 5 Case study: The Threat of Groupthink (Project No: The Threat of Groupthink The group decision making can be regarded as a participatory approach in which individuals critically analyze the problem and put forth their opinions concerning the issue....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

GRoup think on SMall Group about how the class elaborates how people go with the group

Introduction The term ‘groupthink' refers to the exceeding level of unanimity and organizational cohesiveness which normally contribute to faulty decision making.... According to Freeman (1999), a group that is vulnerable to groupthink is less likely to seek alternatives in its decision making processes; moreover, it will heed little attention to distinctive ideas or external assistance (p.... This really reminds us the significance of invoking personal perspectives during the process of decision making in groups....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Group Decision-Making Processes

March and Simon (1958 in Knights and Willmott 2007) identified 'bounded rationality' as an issue for decision making.... Brodbeck et al (2007) note that certain information asymmetries are beneficial for group decision making, while others are not.... Information vigilance instructions (withholding decisions until all available information has been discussed) and having sufficient time for the discussion (to allow for sharing of all available information) contribute to effective group decision making (ibid, p....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Concept of Groupthink

The paper "The Сoncept of groupthink" tells us about what occurs when a group of individuals reaches a consensus without critical reasoning or evaluation of the consequences or alternatives.... The concept of groupthink does not have a positive connotation because it leads to the inadequacy of creativity within a person, distinctiveness, and independent reasoning (Nijstad, 2009).... The occurrence of groupthink leads the members into ignoring the re-evaluation of the other alternatives (Nijstad, 2009)....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Phenomenon of Groupthink Psychology

However, during this period of success the airline had two symptoms of groupthink (Wikipedia, 2013).... Groupthink occurs when team or group members try to reduce conflict so as to attain consensus without making critical assessment of alternative viewpoints or ideas.... The groupthink phenomenon occurs within groups or teams that seek to conform or harmonize their decisions, and thus resulting in deviant or incorrect decision-making outcomes....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Groupthink in the Challenger Space Shuttle Disaster

The paper particularly examines the role of groupthink theory in disaster.... A big part of the paper is dedicated to examining the role of groupthink in the Challenger disaster after which suggestions are provided about how the disaster would have been avoided.... Various decision theories and models have been developed to try and explain how different decisions are reached their outcomes and the impacts of those outcomes on organizations.... This paper ''Groupthink in the Challenger Space Shuttle Disaster'' tells us that decision-making is a very important process that plays a central role in the success or failure of projects....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

How groupthink affects the effectiveness of groups

The major goal of groupthink is to achieve consensus through conflict eradication.... Innovation is not a prime concern as per the concept of groupthink.... However, there are certain positive effects of groupthink in relation to sustaining harmony within a group.... This approach focuses on establishing harmony and it significantly affects the decision-making process.... This study shall outline the relationship between groupthink and group effectiveness....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Role of Groupthink in the Challenger Space Shuttle Disaster

The paper "Role of groupthink in the Challenger Space Shuttle Disaster" is an outstanding example of an essay on management.... The paper "Role of groupthink in the Challenger Space Shuttle Disaster" is an outstanding example of an essay on management.... The paper "Role of groupthink in the Challenger Space Shuttle Disaster" is an outstanding example of an essay on management.... his report discusses the role of groupthink in the Challenger Space Shuttle disaster and will suggest a way in which the situation might have been avoided....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us