StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

William Jennings Byrant's Defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial and Henry Louis Menken's View - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The Scopes Monkey Trial, formally known as The State of Tennessee v. John Thomas Scopes trial, is a watershed event in the history of American justice system. A Tennessee high school science teacher John Scopes was brought to court for violating the state’s Butler Act which prohibited teaching about the theory of evolution. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.3% of users find it useful
William Jennings Byrants Defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial and Henry Louis Menkens View
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "William Jennings Byrant's Defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial and Henry Louis Menken's View"

William Jennings Byrant’s defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial and Henry Louis Menken’s view on the dangers of fundamentalism: Why do you thinkWilliam Jennings Bryant agreed to testify? How serious do you think Mencken was about the danger of fundamentalism? The Scopes Monkey Trial, formally known as The State of Tennessee v. John Thomas Scopes trial, is a watershed event in the history of American justice system. A Tennessee high school science teacher John Scopes was brought to court for violating the state’s Butler Act which prohibited teaching about the theory of evolution.

Although Scopes was found guilty and later let free on technical grounds, the case was still seen by liberal Americans as the first of many battles against fundamental Christianity in the country. (Marcus & Burner, 2010, p.149) The prominent Democratic politician William Jennings Bryan represented the prosecution whereas the reputed defense attorney Clarence Darrow represented Thomas Scopes. A key passage in the trial was when William Jennings Bryant was brought to examination as a witness by Clarence Darrow.

This unconventional move happened on the seventh day of the trial. Historians have presented different rationale for why Bryan agreed to be examined, but it is clear that he thought it would allow him to examine Darrow in turn. Darrow’s questions to Bryan are part of legend today, as they tried to discredit some of the assumptions and beliefs underlying Christian theology. (Marcus & Burner, 2010, p.151) A prime focus of this interview was the question of Adam and Eve. By pointing to logical flaws in the story of Adam and Eve, Darrow was showing to the jury that they were no more than mythologies.

It was at this juncture that the classic exchange between the two counsels’s ensued, with Darrow telling Bryan “You insult every man of science and learning in the world because he does not believe in your fool religion”, to which Bryan responded that “The reason I am answering is not for the benefit of the superior court. It is to keep these gentlemen from saying I was afraid to meet them and let them question me, and I want the Christian world to know that any atheist, agnostic, unbeliever, can question me anytime as to my belief in God, and I will answer him.

” (Scopes, 1925) It is quite clear from this answer that Bryan agreed to be a witness on grounds of principle and on the basis of his deep conviction in the Christian faith. He also went on to accuse Darrow and his team of attempting to “cast ridicule” on honest believers in the Bible. (Scopes, 1925) As the exchange between the two gentlemen got more heated, Judge Raulston was forced to adjourn the proceedings. But since the Judge believed that the examination of Bryan was irrelevant to the actual case, it was cut short and he ordered to expunge the examination from official records.

But, thanks to inventive and bold journalists like H.L Mencken, most details of the trial survive to this day and have spawned more daring arguments and counterarguments from both sides in the years since. (Conkin, 1998, p.185) Representing The Baltimore Sun, H.L. Mencken was passionately involved in the proceedings of the trial. His newspaper even sponsored some of the expenses of the defense team. Mencken believed that the jury was biased in favor of the prosecution. He puts it humorously by calling the jury “unanimously hot for Genesis”.

(Conkin, 1998, p.185) Hence, Mencken served a role far greater than that of mere journalism, for instead of taking a neutral viewpoint he sided with the underdogs in the trial, namely the Scopes team. But his leanings were motivated by his earnest convictions and thoughtful conclusions about the debate. He clearly foresaw the stifling effects of creationism and its associated Christian dogma upon a scientific understanding of our origins. (Conkin, 1998, p.185) Inspired by the merits he saw in Charles Darwin’s Evolution through the Theory of Natural Selection, Mencken believed that he was serving the interests of the general public by supporting critical inquiry in the classroom.

Mencken has a valid point in asserting that personal religious beliefs should have no place in the education system, which should be a free and open place for rational enquiry. The dangers of fundamentalism perceived by Mencken are not out of place, for a brief look into the history of Western Civilization would reveal religious motivations behind some of the most brutal wars. Hence he believed that social divisions on religious lines as well as intolerance towards minorities and non-believers can lead to disastrous outcomes.

This assessment was most shockingly proven correct by the Holocaust of the Second World War where the Roman Catholic Church supported Nazi government nearly wiped out the Jewish population of Europe. The escalating tension between America and its allies on one side and the Islamic fundamentalists on the other side in the ongoing War on Terror operations augurs badly. Hence, in conclusion, one only needs to look at human history to understand Mencken’s genuine concern for the dangers posed by religious fundamentalism.

Since our education system has the power to create and nourish healthy minds that are free of bigotry and prejudice, it is essential that the classroom atmosphere be free and critical debate is encouraged. The abolishing of legal restrictions with respect to teaching evolution will be a good starting point. Works Cited: Examination of Bryan by Clarence Darrow before Judge John T. Raulston and the eulogy for Bryan by H.L. Mencken., America Firsthand Vol II, eighth edition. Authors: Robert Marcus, David Burner and Anthony 2010 pg 148-169.

  Conkin, Paul K. (1998), When All the Gods Trembled: Darwinism, Scopes, and American Intellectuals, pp. 185 pp.,ISBN 0847690636 Scopes, John, The World's Most Famous Court Trial, State of Tennessee vs. John Thomas Scopes: Complete Stenographic Report of the Court, ISBN 0-306-71975-4

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“William Jennings Byrant's Defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1433917-william-jennings-byrant-s-defense-of-the-bible-in
(William Jennings Byrant'S Defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1433917-william-jennings-byrant-s-defense-of-the-bible-in.
“William Jennings Byrant'S Defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1433917-william-jennings-byrant-s-defense-of-the-bible-in.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF William Jennings Byrant's Defense of the Bible in John Scopes Trial and Henry Louis Menken's View

Monkey Trial in the USA

The scopes trial (or Monkey Trial) in Dayton, Tennessee raising the question of controversy between creationism and evolution theory, became an embodiment of this dispute.... john scopes a school teacher from Tennessee was indicted in violation of law by teaching a evolution theory in the public school.... In spite of the reluctant attitude of the American Civil Liberties Union leadership, the defendant john scopes insisted on the Darrow's participation as a defender....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Citing William Appes, Discuss His Bible Based Arguments against Racism

This is often done with the use of the bible.... Some of them are taken from Apess's experience and some of them are based on the bible.... All of them are equal according to the bible.... According to Apess's point of view, there should be no racism in the world because all people are created equal by God.... This point of view is fully demonstrated in the quotation below: “But as I am not looking for a wife … and if I had none, I should not want anyone to take my right from me and choose a wife for me; for I think that I or any of my brethren have a right to choose a wife for themselves as well as the whites - and as the whites have taken the liberty to choose my brethren, the Indians, hundreds and thousands of them, as partners in life, I believe the Indians have as much right to choose their partners among the whites if they wish” (Apess, 94)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Political Personality of Louis Riel in Canada

Name: Tutor: Course: Date: University: louis Riel Introduction louis Riel is regarded as the most1 controversial political personality in Canadian history.... louis Riel and the Red River Rebellion In 1869, the Canadian government signed the Canadian Act of 1869, which introduced a provisional government for the colony in the Red River....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Translation of the New Testament of the Bible

The paper 'Translation of the New Testament of the bible' concerns William Tyndale who is credited by some as being the father of the English language.... A significant part of the fame that has accrued to Tyndale is due to his translation of the New Testament of the bible.... However, Tyndale offered a different view on this, that it was actually the Monarch of England who was the head of the Church since in those days Henry VIII was the ruling head of England....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Does Utilitarianism Clash with John Stuart Mills Theory of Liberty

The author states that through profound arguments, J.... S.... Mill defends individual liberty and individual rights.... His “Utilitarianism” has been criticized from many angles.... Mill is not disposed of kindly to dogmatism in societies and firmly asserts that people know their interests better than others....
9 Pages (2250 words) Term Paper

An Analysis of Piracy Crimes

Additionally, future lawyers should focus on the actual structure and organization of a pirate trial.... The Trials of Joseph Dawson, Edward Forseith, William May, [brace] William Bishop, James Lewis, and john Sparkes commenced on 29th /10/1969 and ended 6th/11/1969 (john p.... They charges for the defendants were read by High court judge, Sir Sc Hedge An analysis of trials for several crimes committed Lecturer: Introduction The Trials of Joseph Dawson, Edward Forseith, William May, [brace] William Bishop, James Lewis, and john Sparkes commenced on 29th /10/1969 and ended 6th/11/1969 (john p....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Scopes Monkey Trial

He was friends with doctor from John Hopkins Scope's Monkey Trial henry louis Mencken H.... (Roberts, 2010)john scopes john scopes was the teacher convicted in Scopes Monkey trial for teaching evolution in school going against the Bulter Act.... ??william jennings Bryan.... Before the Scope's trial Mencken's reports were particularly for the Butler Act but after the trial began his interest grew towards the defendant....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Scopes Trial: People and Events

Mencken played the role of reporting the scopes trial, since he was a reporter for The Baltimore Sun and also the editor of American Mercury; platforms that he used to speak out his mind not only about the case, but also about the people of the South, their culture and… While reporting the case, Mencken did nothing but hate and ridicule the South, while also hating the court prosecutor who was involved in the case.... Most importantly however, Mencken was responsible for persuading Clarence Darrow to take up the case as the scopes trial H....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us