StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Trial court brief - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Trial Brief The following is a trial brief prepared by (insert your name) NEW MEXICO DISTRICT COURT STATE OF NEW MEXICO NO. CIV. 03-388 Plaintiff, JANE WHITE VS. JEFFERY CALKIN Defendant BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS PRELIMINARY STATEMENT Jane White, the plaintiff, collided with Jeffery Calkin, the defendant, who failed to stop at a stop sign…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.1% of users find it useful
Trial court brief
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Trial court brief"

Download file to see previous pages

This memorandum is submitted in opposition to that motion. QUESTION PRESENTED Under the Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act can a negligence claim be stated when a lessor who is self-insured fails to carry insurance. STATEMENT OF THE CASE Sage Rent-A-Car Inc. leased a vehicle to Jeffery Calvin. Mr. Calvin failed to stop at a stop sign and collided with Jane White. Sage did not bear insurance. Ms. White filed a negligent complaint against Sage Rent-A-Car Inc. for the negligent use of the lessor’s vehicle by the lessee.

Sage filed a motion to dismiss the complaint under Rule 1-012B (6) for failure to state claim. ARGUMENT MS. WHITE’S ARGUMENT THAT SAGE HAS DUTY TO ASSUME RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE ACCIDENT IS A SET OF FACTS WHICH, IF PROVEN, WOULD ESTABLISH THE DEFENDANTS DUTY TO CARRY LICENSE AND, THEREFORE, A CLAIM CAN BE STATED AS TO DUTY. This matter is before the court on a Rule 1-012B (6) motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim. In the case Las Lumarias of the N.M. Council v. Isengard, 92 N.M. 297, 300-301 (1978), the New Mexico District Court established the standard for the granting of a 1-012B (6) motion.

The court stated, “A motion to dismiss a complaint is properly granted only when it appears that the plaintiff cannot recover or be entitled to relief under any state of facts provable under the claim…” Sage Rent-A-Car’s motion specifically alleges that a claim cannot be stated in this case with regard to duty. To survive this motion, Ms. White must demonstrate that there is a provable set of facts that would establish the duty of Sage Rent-A-Car Inc. to carry license in this case. The Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act establishes the prevention of a motor owner from permitting the operation of an uninsured motor vehicle.

Section 66-5-205 sets out the duty of Sage Rent-A-Car Inc. It provides, “No owner shall permit the operation of an uninsured motor vehicle, or a motor vehicle for which evidence of financial responsibility as was affirmed to the department is not currently valid, upon the streets or highways of New Mexico unless the vehicle is specifically exempted from the provisions of the Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act…” Section 66-5-218 sets out the procedure for acquiring evidence of financial responsibility: Evidence of financial responsibility, when required under the Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act, may be given by filing: A.

evidence of a motor vehicle insurance policy; B. a surety bond as provided in Section 66-5-225 NMSA 1978; or C. A certificate of deposit of money as provided in Section 66-5-226 NMSA 1978. Section 66-5-207 provides for exempted motor vehicles. It provides, “The following motor vehicles are exempt from the Mandatory Financial Responsibility Act; D. A motor vehicle approved as self-insured by the superintendent of insurance pursuant to Section 66-5-207, 1 NMSA 1978:…” The Act provides for the conditions under which an owner may permit an uninsured vehicle to operate.

It specifies for the exceptions to this rule, and this includes motor vehicles approved as self-insured by the superintendent of insurance. Ms. White’s complaint states that Sage is required to carry a license under the provisions of

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Trial court brief Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1433162-trial-court-brief
(Trial Court Brief Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1433162-trial-court-brief.
“Trial Court Brief Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1433162-trial-court-brief.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Trial court brief

The Powell v. Alabama Case and Courts Ruling

Consequently, our group has agreed with the above discussed dissenting opinions because the trial court had really acted upon the laid down procedures.... Dissenting opinions If right, the judgment that the malfunction of the trial court to grant petitioners time as... Notably, the supreme court of Alabama ruled by a vote of six against one that there was a fair trial.... Considerably, it is noteworthy pointing out that Anderson, the chief justice, produced a tough nonconformist opinion that resulted to an appeal to the Supreme court in the US against the ruling....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Court System in England

hellip; Only the more serious offences are sent to the Crown court to be dealt by a judge and jury.... The first right of the defendant starts when the court says that defendant's presence in the court for any indictable offence is necessary.... There are cases where the defendants are intimidated, threatened, kidnapped or sometimes even eliminated so that they cannot attend the court.... Here the right of the defendant is upheld by making the defendant to ask for either a Crown trial or a Magistrate trial and the choice belongs not to the court, but to the defendant....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Misdemeanors and The Courts

Henry hired an attorney to file a brief to the court on his behalf.... Once the brief had been filed it was given to a panel of justices for review and an oral argument was scheduled.... Now this type of crime is punishable by up to no more than one year in jail and Henry had a court date last week at the Silverton district court.... He checked in at the magistrate court office and pled not guilty to his charge in front of the judge....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Criminal Justice Jury System and Factors Affecting Jury Decisions

An appeals court in the United States described the power of a jury "unreviewable and irreversible" over that of a trail judge.... To provide answers to these, we must examine various issues peculiar with the jury system. … The use of a Common Law trial or Jury was first instituted in England on June 15, 1215.... Accordingly the trial jury acquired veto power over the law and became more powerful than any government official such as Judges....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Crown Court

The following essay "The Crown court" dwells on the peculiarities of the courts of the first instance which deal with criminal law offenses.... It is mentioned that all criminal offenses initially come to the Magistrate court, however, the summary offenses are dealt with here....     Summary offenses dealt with at the Magistrate court include less serious ones such as traffic offenses or failure to pay taxes and will generally include all cases, including triable offenses, where the defendant has opted for a summary trial....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

My Court Visits

In the paper “My court Visits” the author focuses on criminal courts in the English legal system, which are of two types.... hellip; The author states that petty offenses or offenses not serious in nature are dealt with by Magistrates' court.... All cases regarding these offenses are decided entirely in the Magistrates' court.... His case can either be heard by the Magistrates' court or if so desired, he can insist on trial by judge and jury in the Crown court....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

The Appeal Court

hellip; Any defendant or a litigant who did not receive a favorable decision from the trial court can appeal the verdict to a federal court of appeals for its review.... According to the case, the prosecution in the trial court postulated that both Jonathan Parker and Leroy Lewis were narcotics dealers and that Parker had killed his associate Lewis because of his failure to share the robbed cocaine equally among themselves.... The essay "The Appeal court" describes any supporter who lost the case in a court of litigation has the legal right to appeal this decision and ask him to consider it in the federal appellate court....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

A Number of Landmark Court Decisions

The paper 'A Number of Landmark court Decisions' focuses on the court, with the arguable exception of its decision in Betts which has progressively extended the reach of the Sixth Amendment's right to counsel clause to any proceeding that prospectively involves incarceration.... hellip; The author of the paper states that the course that the court might take in Edwards is much more problematic.... In decisions reaching back to the 1950s, the court firmly established a Sixth Amendment right to counsel in cases involving defendants who were mentally retarded or otherwise of diminished mental capacity....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us