StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

How We Could Use Alternative Dispute Resolution To Settle Civil Justice Matters More Efficiently - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Alternative Dispute Resolution or ADR1 (hereafter) constitute specific forms, or combinations thereof, of voluntary, contractual, non-judicial initiatives to resolve civil disputes. ADR for the Department of Constitutional Affairs (DCA2) refers to the "Collective description of methods of resolving disputes otherwise than through the normal trial process."
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.3% of users find it useful
How We Could Use Alternative Dispute Resolution To Settle Civil Justice Matters More Efficiently
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "How We Could Use Alternative Dispute Resolution To Settle Civil Justice Matters More Efficiently"

Download file to see previous pages

The Arbitration Act 1966 and 19965 provided full court application of one of the ADR procedures, following the lead of UNCITRAL's 1958 Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards paving the way to acceptance of arbitration in international trade dispute resolution. The methods were taken up by the public after they have been officially encouraged in Lord Woolf's 1996 "Access to Justice" report.6 The Police (Northern Ireland) Act 20007 is one of the more recent statutes applying ADR to administrative tribunal cases following PACE 1984, infra.

The cost effectiveness of ADR has been fully demonstrated in commercial litigation. It has also placed or misplaced false hopes on the alternative methods application in civil cases. Civil case application of ADR encouraged the proliferation of profit and non-profit ADR providers and services with fully trained and accredited ADR practitioners, most of whom are also solicitors. The CPR required active management of cases by judges, including encouragement of litigating parties to use ADR. For the purpose of facilitating ADR use by litigants, CPR allows the court to stay its proceedings while the parties concerned try to settle the case.

Pre-action protocols were also installed, requiring parties to let each other know the basis of their proposed claims and defences. The importance of ADR is emphasized in several judicial decisions. In Cowl vs. Plymouth9, the Court of Appeals imposed cost sanctions on a party for unreasonable failure to use ADR. Solicitors are also required to apprise clients of ADR, otherwise, they will be considered professionally negligent. Apart from judicial initiative, the executive also introduced ADR in government departments and administrative tribunals, particularly in clinical negligence claims, employment and legal services. Mr. Justice Lightman, a Justice of the High Court Chancery Division, presented ADR with high hopes as a necessary alternative to "extravagantly expensive and unpredictable exercise"10 of litigation.

It must be recognized that ADR is "an ever evolving process."11 Newer methods are being introduced and legislation, including rules of court would tend to be left behind. Current consensus among law practioners tend to limit ADR use to arbitration and mediation. The failure of the use of inappropriate ADR method force the parties to incur needless expenses. On this note, the observations of Sir Anthony Evans triggers a painful spot when he pointed out that it is the agreement of the parties to come to a settlement that is responsible for the supposed success of ADR and not ADR processes themselves.

In fact, he emphasized that "a settlement agreement is always to be preferred to any of the [ADR] processes which may result in a binding decision".12 He meant that solicitors and judges should look at the nature of the case before influencing the parties to undergo ADR procedures that could be inappropriate and ineffective. He also pointed out

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“How We Could Use Alternative Dispute Resolution To Settle Civil Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1501950-how-we-could-use-alternative-dispute-resolution-to-settle-civil-justice-matters-more-efficiently
(How We Could Use Alternative Dispute Resolution To Settle Civil Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1501950-how-we-could-use-alternative-dispute-resolution-to-settle-civil-justice-matters-more-efficiently.
“How We Could Use Alternative Dispute Resolution To Settle Civil Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1501950-how-we-could-use-alternative-dispute-resolution-to-settle-civil-justice-matters-more-efficiently.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF How We Could Use Alternative Dispute Resolution To Settle Civil Justice Matters More Efficiently

The Common Law in the US

Over the centuries, many people have believed that juries in most cases reach a fairer and more just result than would be obtained using a judge alone, as many... hellip; English law is regarded as a common law rather than a civil law system (i.... there has been no major codification of the law, and judicial precedents are binding as opposed to persuasive). Although devolution has accorded some degree of autonomy to Wales politically, it still doesn't have and sovereign powers of law-making, thus the legal system administered through criminal and both civil courts remains unified. During the early centuries, the judges and justices were responsible for adapting the Writ system to meet everyday needs, and the application of a mixture of common sense and precedent in order to create a body of internally consistent law....
11 Pages (2750 words) Article

Construction Contracts and its Relation with Alternative Dispute Resolution

Bullard The essay will present relevant provisions of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act of 1996, the Pre-Action Protocol for Construction and Engineering Disputes, The Woolf Report, as well as information about litigation, arbitration and alternative dispute resolution or ADR and the costs involved.... This essay will examine the importance of alternative dispute resolution in resolving and expediting cases between and among the parties.... Bullard will be used along with relevant provisions of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act of 1996, The Woolf Report, Pre-Action Protocol for the Construction and Engineering Disputes and other current and relevant materials to alternative dispute resolution and Construction Contract Law....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

Legal Systems in Modern Civilization

The capacities of traditional, informal dispute resolution institutions to resolve disputes, such as the family, neighborhood or church, seem to have diminished.... There is a perception too that as a people we have become more litigious.... There is a growing awareness that the corner-stone of our judicial structure, the adversary system itself, is not the most appropriate for the effective resolution of all forms of disputes; it may not be capable of resolving a problem to both parties' satisfaction and may easily cause disputes to escalate to more serious levels....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Alternative Dispute Resolution

The process of alternative dispute resolution (or ADR for short) is not new to the present generation.... Mediation is actually a class or a form of an alternative dispute resolution process.... Such a situation will give more elbow room and latitude for the judges in dispensing their functions more efficiently, effectively and speedily.... It is one of several ways to resolve disputes outside the ambit of the courts or to make an attempt to settle the case if possible....
16 Pages (4000 words) Essay

The Evaluative and Facilitatory Mediation Processes

However, the evaluative mode of mediation is increasingly being likened to a court style adversarial approach and the differences developing between the facilitatory style and the evaluative style raise the question of whether it is appropriate to include both these forms of alternative dispute resolution under the common umbrella of mediation.... The spirit behind mediation is that of allowing a resolution to a dispute that is negotiated by the parties in a non adversarial environment....
57 Pages (14250 words) Essay

US Appellate Court Decisions Relating to Presidential Powers

683, Decided, July 24, 1974, by a unanimous vote (8-0, Justice Rehnquist having… 2 Facts of the case: A District of Columbia grand jury returned indictments against a number of President Nixon's office staff in matters relating to the Watergate burglary and the related White House efforts at a cover-up.... That document makes no reference to executive privilege, although it privileges Members of Congress in matters relating to debate (Art.... Clair) argued that the special prosecutor, functioning as an employee of the Department of justice, made any request for White House audiotapes an internal matter to be resolved within the Executive Branch....
24 Pages (6000 words) Essay

Advantages and Disadvantages of Alternative Dispute Resolution

The author of the assignment examines the advantages and disadvantages of alternative dispute resolution.... nbsp; alternative dispute resolution (ADR) refers to various mechanisms used to settle disputes other by the means of the court system.... Therefore, ADR is can be a cost-effective dispute resolution mechanism though this will be only applicable in cases where there is a successful settlement of the issues between the parties involved....
13 Pages (3250 words) Assignment

Alternative Dispute Resolution

alternative dispute resolution (ADR) is any method or means of resolving or settling disputes, which is carried out outside the courtroom and is not litigation.... The first major purpose of using alternative dispute resolution (ADR) as opposed to Litigation is to speed up the process of dispute settlement.... Negotiations, on the other hand, are usually attempted as the first method of dispute resolution by most individuals or people who find themselves amidst conflicts....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us