StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia State Bar Association - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The organization of the Virginia State Bar was done in 1938 through a General Assembly Act. The Virginia State Bar is a true representative of Virginia lawyers as its life is characterized by more than 1,000 members have been served from the Bar’s numerous committees and offices. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia State Bar Association
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia State Bar Association"

The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia Bar Association al Affiliation The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia Bar Association The organization of the Virginia State Bar was done in 1938 through a General Assembly Act. The Virginia State Bar is a true representative of Virginia lawyers as its life is characterized by more than 1,000 members have been served from the Bar’s numerous committees and offices. The membership of the Virginia State Bar is restricted to five categories that are active members, associate members, disabled and retired members, judicial members, and the emeritus members. Each group of members has defined roles and responsibilities that are aimed at ensuring the Bar’s responsibility to the state is achieved in the most integrated way possible. Members also belong to different committees with the Judicial Candidate Evaluation Committee being responsible for the consideration and search of appropriate nominees to fill any judicial vacancies (Virginia State Bar Council, 2012, p. n.p). The constitution of the committee is thirteen active members. These members are carefully selected to ensure that each of the ten existing disciplinary districts in Virginia is represented, while the other three are from the state. Each member’s election restricts them to remain in office for only three year terms after which they are no longer eligible candidates. In addition, the election of the committee members is by the Council upon the recommendation of the nominating committee. The major role of this committee is to ensure that any judicial vacancy is filled with the right candidate. The process involves first considering and appropriately searching for the right nominees. Finally, a committee member from a given Virginia State Bar disciplinary district is assigned the responsibility of scrutinizing any identified nominees from their district in Virginia (Virginia State Bar Council, 2012). The vacancies that require such nominations are often in the Supreme Court of Virginia, the State Corporation Commission, and Virginia Seat on the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, and the Court of Appeals of Virginia. Each investigation brings out a report before the JCEC then interviews them. Upon investigation, the candidates are then voted for qualification and putting into consideration the committee policy requirements of integrity, experience, temperament, professional competence, public service, and civic activities (Warner & Kaine, 2014, p. 1). As active members, the members of the Virginia Judicial Candidate Evaluation Committee are admitted to practice law in Virginia as attorneys and are also engaged, whether part time or full time, salaried or not, in practicing law (The Virginia State Bar, 2010). Like most American States, Virginia State continues to use an electoral system to appoint and retain its judges. However, this is disadvantageous since nominees have to campaign and this is time consuming and expensive, and the judges find themselves ethical dilemma situations. Furthermore, such campaigns cause even the lowest ranking judges to receive reappointments despite proof of eminent unfairness and eminent disqualification like the case of Judge Birdie Hairston Jamison (Fain, 2014). For some judges like Lucas D-Portsmouth, the act involved systematic bias even though Jamison was a female from the minority black people. Virginia State Bar Association- Alternative Dispute Resolution Besides its responsibility in the selecting candidates for judicial positions, the JCEC in Virginia is responsible for addressing professional ethics and standards of practice; enlightening ADR professionals and lawyers regarding trending issues and opportunities in the field through the Virginia ADR newsletter, CLE programs, and the website; developing creative uses of ADR processes and Strategies to offer improved services to clients; and monitoring public and legislation policy. In the State of Virginia, ADR is the responsibility of a Joint Dispute Resolution Committee that is active in all areas of ADR, including conciliation, negotiation, arbitration, mediation, restorative justice, settlement conferences, and collaborative law. Mediation process involves dispute resolution at a point where the disputes are huge enough to involve lawsuits, or where disputes are yet to become lawsuits but may require litigation for failure of successful mediation. Either way, the JCEC understands that legal norms play a crucial role in disputes, particularly where the parties have filed suit and where the parties have not filed suit. As the parties get into mediation, process, they often raise questions or issues regarding what they should consider as their legal responsibilities or legal rights. The search for the right answers may involve the mediation of a mediator in evaluating or clarifying legal perspectives. Conversely, the mediator may seek for answers to reality-testing questions implicating lawful issues by the parties. This way, the mediator manages to offer legal information and engage in activities that facilitate considerate and informed decision making by the disputing parties. In Virginia, the absence of appellate courts’ mediator activities has not been considered. This is because the state’s dispute resolution proceedings directly affect the issue of practicing law and mediation present in state statutes, court rules, VSB legal ethic opinions, and conventions of ethics (The Virginia State Dispute Resolution Services Advisory Committee, 2001). For instance, the Virginia code considers the act of practicing law without authorization or license as a misdemeanor. In order to govern mediation in Virginia, the code of Virginia constitutes the main original mediation statute that defines mediation, explains mediation confidentiality, and defining the mediators’ permissible immunity. The Virginia State Bar Association Joint Committee on dispute resolution explored the art of establishing legislation to facilitate courts referral to maters of alternative dispute resolution proceedings and offer mechanisms of ADR mechanisms within court settings. In addition, the Code of Virginia’s § 8.01-576.4 permits judges to demand appropriate civil cases to free dispute resolution evaluation section such that each party can evaluate whether they are still in need of an ADR proceeding. Furthermore, Section 5 of the code of Virginia gives courts the mandate of referring contented civil cases to dispute resolution evaluation session aimed at ensuring the parties receive relevant assistance in assessing the case and choosing the pursuit of dispute resolution or proceed with adjudication. The mediator Standards of Ethics also promotes ADR through its guidance on ethical principles, the need for more comprehensive and particular ethical rules to clarify matters concerning the mediator conduct (The Virginia State Dispute Resolution Services Advisory Committee, 2001). For instance, through section D of the standards, the mediator must ensure that each party receives a written documentation that the mediator is not a legal advisor, the parties’ legal rights are affected by mediation, and that both parties can seek legal counsel, and the review of the draft agreement with the independent counsel. In Section E of the standards, the mediator is not expected to coerce any party to enter into an agreement or choose for any party. On the contrary, the mediator should only offer information in areas that the parties qualify to receive training or have the information provided. While mediation follows a more formal and structured organization, conciliation process involves a neutral facilitating dispute settlement through clarification of issues and acting as the negotiation intermediary in a way that is less formal and less structured. Ways of Disciplining Judges The Virginia State Bar Association comprises of a disciplinary board and is genuinely concerned regarding complaints, thus subjecting complaints to evaluation, and the public together with the volunteer lawyers decide the merits of the complaint at hand. Like lawyers, judges should be subjected to preliminary investigations in order to define the complaints’ merits (The Office of Bar Counsel Virginia State Bar, 2011). A second investigation should involve district committee investigators to interview the judges and the process requires patience. The findings could impose low level or high level discipline depending on the proof of misconduct available, thus retaining or dismissing complaints appropriately. My Recommendations My recommendation would be to ensure that the due process entails equal applications of law and procedure to all candidate evaluation and selection decision making processes. However, the JCEC members must be aware that not everyone would be satisfied with their results, but that at all times the laws, and not the people’s will reigns. In addition, I would recommend that the decision making process is open enough to involve the public as this would develop the delivery of justice and reinforce the public respect for judicial selection. References Fain, T. (2014, December 15). Bias alleged in Virginias judicial evaluations. Daily Press. The Office of Bar Counsel Virginia State Bar. (2011). Guide to Lawyer Discipline. Richmond: The Office of Bar Counsel. The Virginia State Bar. (2010, March 23). Professional Guidelines. Retrieved June 6, 2015 The Virginia State Dispute Resolution Services Advisory Committee. (2001). Mediation Resources-Unauthorized Practice of Law. Virginia: Virginia State Bar. Virginia State Bar Council. (2012, June 14). Nominations Committee Name Change, Policies Approved. Retrieved June 6, 2015 Warner, M., & Kaine, T. (2014). Virginia State Bar. Virginia: Virginia State Bar. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia State Bar Association Essay”, n.d.)
The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia State Bar Association Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1697062-the-judiciary-committee-of-the-virginia-state-bar-association
(The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia State Bar Association Essay)
The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia State Bar Association Essay. https://studentshare.org/law/1697062-the-judiciary-committee-of-the-virginia-state-bar-association.
“The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia State Bar Association Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1697062-the-judiciary-committee-of-the-virginia-state-bar-association.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Judiciary Committee of the Virginia State Bar Association

Jury system of United States

quoted the idea of juries in virginia Colony is, "When the case was given to the jury, it was locked up without food or water until it reached a verdict.... To know what is right and what is wrong in the world of criminals; jury system has been developed.... The objective of jury system is to provide the feeling of guilt and innocence to the accused people what they actually deserve....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Virginia Local and State Government

reeti 11/5/2008 VIRGINIA GOVERNMENT the virginia Government was framed in a manner that would make it accountable to the people living in the region and would serve the public with utmost dedication and loyalty.... In my view, this system of 'term limit' can be altered to suit the current needs of the state and its governmental functioning.... The term limits could be decided upon, for the members of the state Senate and differently for the House of Delegates....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Virginia State Government

According to the virginia Disaster Recovery newsletter, President Bill Clinton declared a state and Number Due Regular Recipient of FEMA Funds Although the largest natural disasters, like Hurricane Katrina, receive most of our attention, smaller disaster occur quite frequently, and the state of Virginia is a regular recipient of funds from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).... According to the virginia Disaster Recovery newsletter, President Bill Clinton declared a state of emergency on Sept....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

State Court System In Indiana

The constitution gives the judicial power of the state to a Supreme Court, a Court of Appeals, circuit courts, and any other courts that… Trial Courts and appellate courts makes up the two kinds of Indiana state courts.... In trial courts, any civil or criminal case can be heard for they have the power to do so....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Compare and Contrast the Virginia and New Jersey Plans Presented at the Constitutional Convention

This paper, Compare and Contrast the virginia and New Jersey Plans Presented at the Constitutional Convention, outlines that a comparison between Virginia and the New Jersey plans presented at the Constitutional Convention reveals some fundamental structural differences between the two plans.... the virginia plan supports the creation of national branches of government, with national jurisdiction.... A comparison between the virginia and the New Jersey plans presented at the constitutional Convention reveals some fundamental structural differences between the two plans....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Judiciary Assignment

During the first night, the security officer forced a drunken patron from the bar and locked it earlier because of the disturbing… On the second night, the community members met at the resort bar to celebrate a wedding, it was during the period that tension among the communities developed.... During the first night, the security officer forced a drunken patron from the bar and locked it earlier because of the disturbing situation.... On the second night, the community members met at the resort bar to celebrate a wedding, it was during the period that tension among the communities developed....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Counter Terrorism Constitutional and Legislative Issues

citizen and was transferred to a naval brig in Norfolk, virginia.... & 2241 in the Eastern District of virginia, naming the petitioners as his son and himself as his next friend.... The current research paper "Counter Terrorism Constitutional and Legislative Issues" investigates the events of September 11, when the terrorist group – Al –Qaeda hijacked commercial airliners and attacked prominent targets - The World Trade Center and the Pentagon, in the United States....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper

Divorce in the State of Virginia

hellip; The issue of divorce does not only entail the end of a marriage or union between the two individuals involved, but also other relevant and complex legal issues such as the sharing of property, the custody of the children, the financing of the children's lifestyle, among other fine legal details (virginia state bar, 2013).... This is a qualified type of divorce, under which the parties involved can then go back to the court and petition the court to merge the divorce into a divorce from the bond of matrimony after one year has passed from the date the two were legally separated (virginia state bar, 2013)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us