StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Justice System Book by Neubauer and Fradella - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper contains a description of 7 and 8 Chapters of "America’s Courts and the Criminal Justice System" book authored by Neubauer and Fradella. The author also describes the three ways someone can become a judge and identifies which of the pathways results in the selection of the best judges …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.9% of users find it useful
Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Justice System Book by Neubauer and Fradella
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Justice System Book by Neubauer and Fradella"

Chapter 7 & 8Q#1: (Chapter 7) illustrates how defense attorneys can be subject to informal sanctions and rewards. The chapter also highlights how variations in cooperation with the other actors in the courthouse by the defense attorney can affect the defendant. Is a defendant better served by a hard fighting attorney “the gambler” or someone who works within the established norms?(Neubauer and Fradella) Which would you want if you were the defendant? Explain your position.If I were a defendant, I would like to have a defense attorney who works within the established norm-within the system.

The assertion by Neubauer and Fradella (170) that defense attorneys’ working within the set norms and in cooperation with the court community do not best represent the interests of the client is in my opinion incorrect and fallacious. It is worth noting that, this interaction or cooperation between a defense attorney and other courtroom workgroups does not erode the best interests of a defendant (171) but rather, betters the results for a client. This is because; such a defense attorney gets access to helpful, important information from the prosecutor, which he/she would otherwise have no access to.

As a client, a defense attorney who takes a cooperative posture may help thee attorney get favorable bargains-plea bargains-, and would, in addition, shield a client from being penalized as a result of the defense attorney’s hostility. Neubauer and Fradella (171) argue that, the so called “gambling” attorneys may harm their clients since they may, in a bad way push the judges’ and prosecutor’s hand into handing a client long and unreasonable sentences.Further, an attorney working within the set norms and in cooperation with other courtroom groups are considered good counselors and sober advisors since they have the capability to predict and ascertain the reactions of the court community with regards to certain cases.

This gives them an upper hand when it comes to offering a client advice with respect to how to proceed with a case. This implies that, such attorneys have the ability to develop realistic and strategic approaches to cases on the basis of knowledge and experience. Moreover, in retrospect to what many studies have advanced, attorney’s cooperating and interacting with other courtroom groups have the motivation to defend their clients vigorously and have the capability to go to trial where and when, in their judgment, it seems necessary.

Q#2: (Chapter 8) describes the three ways someone can become a judge. Which of the three pathways do you believe results in the selection of the best judges? Explain your position.My position with regards to which selection process-executive appointment, election or meritocracy selection-, is best is based on various factors. Therefore, it is difficult to conclusive confirm which criterion is generally the best, but on the basis of various interpretations I can take a position. For instance, on the basis of the quality of judgment a judge would dispense, I would hold the position that the Missouri Bar Plan or the meritocracy selection process is the best process for the selection of quality judges.

Borrowing from the arguments advanced by judicial reformers, it is important to complete make courts free of politics. This is because; elected or appointed judges tend to take the populist posture while deciding cases. The merit collection process tends to cure these ills and in some way incorporate elements of the other-election and appointed-processes (Neubauer and Fradella 194). This process has increased the participation of legal professionals and has significantly reduced the influence by political parties in the selection process.

Works CitedNeubauer, David W., and Henry F. Fradella. America’s Courts and the Criminal Justice System. 10th ed. Belmont, CA: Cengage Learning, 2010. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Coursework”, n.d.)
Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Coursework. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1793301-7-8
(Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Coursework)
Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Coursework. https://studentshare.org/law/1793301-7-8.
“Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Coursework”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1793301-7-8.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Description of 7 and 8 Chapters of Americas Courts and the Criminal Justice System Book by Neubauer and Fradella

Men in Black How the Supreme Court is Destroying America

The author of this book review "Men in Black How the Supreme Court is Destroying America" casts light on the American Constitution and the system of government.... But in this sophisticated and riveting book that is what Levin argues has happened in recent years.... hroughout this book, Levin describes many examples of judicial interference in the lives of Americans.... The book is largely written for an educated audience that is interested in law and politics....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Five Roads to the Future Critical Review

book Review: ‘Five Roads to the Future: Power in the Next Global Age' by Paul Starobin Introduction Every great or small literature is documentation of the time, society and age of which it has evolved.... Needless to mention that the perspective from which the author of the book views his age, society and time get captivated in the valuable and engaging documents those stand out as a mark of the contemporary time long after the dates of its first appearance and publication ‘Five Roads to the Future: Power in the Next Global Age' by Paul Starobin, which is not only an engaging study about the future global politics but is a definite doorway to the future too....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

A Procedural Analysis of Gideons Trumpet

1 Professor Name Date A Procedural Analysis of Gideon's Trumpet It's ironic that a book about the landmark case of Gideon vs.... Abe Fortas, who would later join the Court as an Associate justice, argued Gideon's case.... The Supreme Court found, in a unanimous decision written by justice Hugo L.... Constitution in federal criminal cases... Wainright, courts decided on a case by case basis whether an indigent defendant would be represented by legal counsel that had been appointed to them....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Critique of the Book America's Constitution:A Biography by Akhil Amar

Subject: History and Political Science Date: March 30, 2012 Topic: Critique of book "America's Constitution: A Biography" by Akhil Amar Introduction This is the book with a difference, on America's Constitution.... What the book was about?... Akhil Reed Amar writes, “Law, history and political science—these three disciplines form the legs of the stool on which the book rests.... In the chapters that follow I offer my own take: This book is an opinionated biography of the document....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

The Death and Life of the Great American School System by Diane Ravitchs

A book Review on Diane Ravitch's The Death and Life of the Great American School System Review/Critique Questions 1.... My Position on the tension Ravitch describes in the book In relation to the changing times today, it is likely that Ravitch argument on the tensions concerning self-directed individualism, individual accountability, and rationalization is probable.... However, in her review on Ravitch's book, Windhorst (2010) said the viability of teaching accountability and rationalization is more beneficial in today's society, considering that learning to adapt to social situations is a highly-valued skill today (p....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review

Journal of Ch 9 and 10 in Book, and review 5 court cases

Cases Name: Institution: Chapter 9 and 10 of the book criminal procedures and practice appreciates the many tasks that are legally professional and initiate the ideas of processing all cases in the criminal justice systems.... This is according to the readings provided by justice White of the Florida Supreme Courts.... 735 This court was proceeded by justice Brennan who was later joined by justice Marshall.... In learning these procedures, it is possible to understand and identify diverse ways in which laws about criminal cases are enforced in relation to the officials of the specific cases....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Summary for this particular book. for criminal justice class

To work for the criminal justice system one either gets patient or gets started even on a small scale level on the relevant reforms to better the system.... Working in the criminal justice system, one can only start from an individual level and interact with the victims.... The first deduction is that there are many obstacles to the legal justice system such as jurisdictions and bureaucracy.... The first deduction is that there are many obstacles to the legal justice system such as jurisdictions and bureaucracy....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review

Justice and Court Proceedings

rdquo; the criminal justice system is negatively skewed in providing lasting solutions to social problems.... I have therefore learned that a wide approach to various problems in the criminal justice system is necessary to offer a long-lasting solution.... Most importantly, I have learned that the effectiveness of any criminal justice system primarily depends on an understanding of defendants rather than offering justice to the affected.... It is evident that the justice system is specifically tailored for the rich in society....
1 Pages (250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us