StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Appearance Versus Essence in Monkey and Tartuffe - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The objects of analysis for the purpose of this paper "Appearance Versus Essence in Monkey and Tartuffe" are two works of literature that explore the discrepancy between appearance and essence: Ch'eng-en's “Journey to the West” or “Monkey” and Molliere's play,  “Tartuffe.”…
Download free paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.2% of users find it useful
Appearance Versus Essence in Monkey and Tartuffe
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Appearance Versus Essence in Monkey and Tartuffe"

August 2, Human versus Spiritual Essence in “Monkey” and “Tartuffe” Two works of literature explore the discrepancy between appearance and essence: Ch'eng-en's “Journey to the West” or “Monkey” and Molliere's play, “Tartuffe.” “Tartuffe” explores the superficiality of religiousness, while “Journey to the West” examines the ambiguities of disguise and real intentions. This essay studies the unreliability of appearances, re-surfacing of truth, vision of justice, and interplay between essence and appearance, reality and falsehood, truth and disguise and how they affect the readers' understanding of the works themselves and of the social contexts they reflect. Many people are deceived by appearances, because they “want” to be deceived, since appearance is easier to accept than taking effort in examining the essence of others and of life, but justice soon acts upon humanity, either by the measures of the gods, as in the “Monkey” or the actions of people in authority, like in “Tartuffe,” where truth resurfaces either through the awakening of human essence or spiritual essence. People generally want to be deceived, because they would rather consume falsehood than address the reality of unjust appearances; examining essence in others entails a cumbersome critical thinking exercise that not all wants to endure. Orgon has fallen in love with Tartuffe's appearance of a pious man. On the one hand, it shows Orgon's desire for an upright companion. In Act 1, Scene V, Dorine focuses on reporting to Orgon about his wife's illness, but the latter is only interested in knowing about Tartuffe's welfare. He keeps on saying: “And how about Tartuffe?” Dorine hits the mark, when she says earlier in Act 1, Scene II that “[Orgon] calls him [Tartuffe], loves him/ A hundred times as much as mother, son,/Daughter, and wife...” (Moliere). She uses verbal irony to say that her master is interested in his wife's well-being, when in reality, he is focused on absorbing Tartuffe's “poor” conditions (Moliere 1.5). This reflects the sentiments of Moliere's society on the absence of godliness in modern living. On the other hand, Orgon represents humanity's weakness for the false “gods.” In his case, Tartuffe is the false deity that he worships. Orgon admires Tartuffe's religiousness, where in their first meeting, the latter makes “deep-drawn sighs and great ejaculations” to God (Moliere 1.6). The same happens in “Monkey,” where people also concentrate on false icons. As the Monkey King looks for Immortals, Sages, and Buddhas on earth, he sees that “...the people of the world were too concerned with fame and fortune to be interested in their fates...” (Ch'eng-en 13). This is the same materialism that Orgon and his mother hate in the world, nevertheless. They cherish people who go beyond the material sphere of living too. The main difference on this topic of appearance and essence between the two stories is that “Tartuffe” satirizes the virtuous, while “Monkey” exalts and cherishes the “spiritually enlightened.” Cleante tells Orgon that the primary downfall of “religious men” are that they call people with “good eyes” as “atheists” and if these atheists do not “adore their vain grimaces,” they will be judged as having no “faith nor care for sacred things” (Moliere 1.6). Moliere is saying that people are hypocrites to heap criticisms upon atheists, when the latter are more enlightened about human essence. “Monkey,” on the contrary, upholds the religiousness of humanity, because they are the ones with opened eyes. For Ch'eng-en, only when people have reached a state of holiness can they achieve “higher” levels of “being,” such as becoming a Buddha, Immortal, or Sage. The Monkey King leaves his carefree, elite life behind to pursue this “religiousness” that “Tartuffe” condemns. Religiousness focuses on the spiritual essence and the fate after death. Pious people represent the antithesis of humanity who “have no time to stop and think” (Ch'eng-en 14). Since “Monkey” upholds Buddhism, the story revolves around the monk Sanzang, whose mission is to go to the Western Heavens and ask the Buddha for the holy scriptures. This mission shows early Chinese society's esteem for spiritual growth. Some examples of unreliability of appearances are the appearances of lower and upper class, hypocrisy of religiousness, and difference between the false and truthful scriptures. Even maids can be more intelligent than their masters, because they see through appearances, which makes the former have more “essence” or substance in their thinking. Dorine sees the hypocrite that Tartuffe is, while her masters Ogron and Madame Pernelle do not. She tells them that Tartuffe “passes for a saint in your opinion [when] he's nothing but a hypocrite” (Moliere Act 1 Scene 1). Madame Pernelle belittles the maid, because of her social status, but praises Tartuffe, due to the latter's superficial appearance: “I don't know what the servant's character. May be; but I can guarantee the master, a holy man” (Moliere 1.1). Madame Pernelle believes that Tartuffe is a holy man and tells Tartuffe's detractors: “He wants to guide you on the way to heaven” (Moliere 1.1). “Monkey” focuses on the other lower class, the animals versus the upper class of the human race. The Monkey King has just entered earth to search for immortality, which can be learned from the Immortals, Buddhas, and Sages. The Monkey King realizes, however, that the people are not concerned of more important issues: “He observed that the people of the world were too concerned with fame and fortune to be interested in their fates” (Ch'eng-en 13). These people are not worried of the King of Hell and no longer stop and reflect on their future, in the same way that the Monkey King does (Ch'eng-en 13). Indeed, when the Monkey King meets a woodcutter, this man is more concerned of the material needs of his family than the improvement of his conduct. “Monkey” exemplifies the conflict between physical human nature and spiritual nature. The story emphasizes, however, that the Monkey King wants to be immortal for selfish, self-aggrandizement reasons. By these reasons alone, he is unfit for immortality in the beginning of the story. Furthermore, “Monkey” again highlights its moralistic theme. It differentiates the false from truthful scriptures. The Bodhisattva reveals to Sanzang that his knowledge of the vehicles is limited to the “Little Vehicle,” which is why he must travel to the West to learn about “the Great Vehicle that will raise the dead up to Heaven, deliver sufferers from their torments, and free souls from” reincarnation (Ch'eng-en 186). These examples of appearances demonstrate the superficiality of the “physical” and the importance of the “inner” essences. Justice soon acts upon humanity, either by the measures of the gods, as in the “Monkey” or the actions of people in authority, like in “Tartuffe,” where truth resurfaces, because characters achieve the grace of human or spiritual essence. “Monkey” underlines the power of the gods to execute human and heavenly justice. When the Monkey King's arrogance hurt the Dragon Kings and Peach fairies, they all report to the Jade Emperor to correct these wrongs. Even after the provision of the grand title of Great Sage Equaling Heaven, the Monkey King continues with his evil deeds, and so the gods and the Buddha exact an equal penalty for the Monkey King. The Monkey King, however, slowly realizes his spiritual essence in his journey to the West. In “Tartuffe,” the people are the ones who resurface the truth. Tartuffe exposes his evil essence, when he professes love to Elmire in secrecy and tells her: “Though pious, I am none the less a man” who desires a married woman (Moliere 3.3). Damis overhears everything and tells Orgon, who acts like a deaf to the truth. He prefers the appearance of piety to the harsh reality that he has seen essence in a man of no essence. People, furthermore, serve justice in “Tartuffe,” while justice represents the fit between one's deeds and resulting rewards and punishments in the Heaven or Hell, according to “Monkey.” “Monkey” says that the punishment in hell fits the life lived on earth: “...They offended against Heaven by not being loyal or filial... so fell down here./The Grinding Hell, the Pounding Hell, the Hell of Drawing and Quartering...”(Ch'eng-en 157). Different layers of hell await the sinner in the “Monkey.” “Tartuffe” asserts that people do not have to wait for the afterlife to suffer for their sins. The last scene demonstrates the reversal of Tartuffe's fortune. Apparently, the prince “knows the false, and views it with disgust” (Moliere 5.7). He realizes the appearance of Tartuffe and fixes Orgon's life for him by giving him back his property. This represents justice in human terms. In addition, “Monkey” highlights justice through rewards in the afterlife. Xiang Liang lives a pious life, where he gives his extra money and possessions to monks: “Although he was only a pious pauper in this world, he owned mountains of jade and gold in the other one” (Ch'eng-en 170). Justice in “Tartuffe” is more pragmatic than spiritual, when Orgon has his free life and property restored to him. Because the prince reinstates his property, Orgon kneels to him and not to the gods. Appearances deceive, but many times, people will rather choose blindness over seeking the truth. “Tartuffe” shows that people will learn the truth and give justice on their own, without spiritual guidance. “Monkey” teaches the essence of godliness in searching for truth. In both stories, justice equals one's merits or misdeeds, but “Monkey” ensures the fairness and harshness of justice in the afterlife too. These stories remark that appearances are fleeting, and only the essence of goodness can be rewarded, in this life or the next, or even in both. Works Cited Ch'eng-en, Wu. Monkey (Journey to The West). Web. 31 July 2011 . Moliere, Jean Baptiste Poquelin. Tartuffe. Web. 31 July 2011 . Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Appearance versus Essence in Monkey and Tartuffe Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/literature/1429854-appearance-versus-essence-in-monkey-and-tartuffe
(Appearance Versus Essence in Monkey and Tartuffe Book Report/Review)
https://studentshare.org/literature/1429854-appearance-versus-essence-in-monkey-and-tartuffe.
“Appearance Versus Essence in Monkey and Tartuffe Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/literature/1429854-appearance-versus-essence-in-monkey-and-tartuffe.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Appearance Versus Essence in Monkey and Tartuffe

Tartuffe character analysis

) – and tartuffe.... Character Analysis: Orgon's Women Relatives in tartuffe tartuffe, ou L'Imposteur is one of the French playwright Moliere's most famous works.... First performed in 1664, and for a while thereafter censored and banned for religious controversy, the play tells the story of a man – tartuffe himself – who makes use of affected religiosity to trick the head of a family (Orgon) into signing over “all [Orgon's] property” (Moliere, III....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Tartuffe as One of Moliere's Most Famous Plays

tartuffe is one of Moliere's most famous plays, written in 1664 and performed at the fêtes for King Louis XIV.... Moliere's tartuffe tartuffe is one of Moliere's most famous plays, written in 1664 and performed at the fetes for King Louis XIV.... The play has been so influential that tartuffe is now a synonym for hypocrite in both English and French.... The purpose of this paper is to discuss whether it is indeed tartuffe that is the main villain of the play, or if Orgon, the householder, has to shoulder some of the blame....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Appearance and Deception in Tartuffe

Name Instructor Class April 22, 2012 Appearance and Deception in tartuffe Some of the religious and virtuous people are actually the worst liars and hypocrites.... This is the main goal of tartuffe in a play that has his name, written by Moliere.... tartuffe pretends to be a pious man, a ruse that enables him to manipulate people like Orgon and Madame Pernelle.... They see beyond tartuffe's appearance and believe that he is an expert hypocrite, although they have difficulty in convincing Orgon in seeing the truth, until he sees the truth with his own eyes....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

The Use of Satire in Tartuffe by Moliere

"The Use of Satire in tartuffe by Moliere" paper focuses on a comedy written by Moliere and 'was first performed before Louis XIV at Versailles in 1664'.... The characters in the play include tartuffe, Orgon, Elmire, Dorine, Cleante, Mariane, Damis, Madame Pernelle, Valere, and a police officer.... The use of satire in the play can be seen in tartuffe, who appears to be a very religious man, but he is a hypocrite.... This is because when he arrives in Orgon's house, tartuffe possesses as a poor, but the extremely religious man of God....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Moliere's Tartuffe

That Moliere created his famously controversial work, tartuffe, during what Morizot has characterized as an "Age of Quarrels" (2006: n.... The conventional wisdom is that Moliere sought to point out religious hypocrisy through tartuffe; a more reasoned and nuanced approach would probe deeper and conclude that Moliere was more interested in the dangers of absolutism in any form than with religion more specifically.... his essay will argue that the pattern of conflicts created by Moliere, and best exemplified through the relationships cultivated by tartuffe, were avoidable in large part but for the blind reliance of certain characters on unproven assumptions underlying certain types of absolutism....
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Comedy Litterature/ Moliere's Tartuffe

Although tartuffe is the clear villain and charlatan who embody those people who advocate religious devoutness but they themselves refuse to put into practice, The Satire of Moliere's tartuffe Moliere's tartuffe is definitely a satire.... Hence, due to tartuffe's sardonic character, the play was banned by religious supporters from public performance.... Although tartuffe is the clear villain and charlatan who embody those people who advocate religious devoutness but they themselves refuse to put into practice, Orgon has the intricate role through whom this pious insincerity is directed....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Analysis of Tartuffe Play

He argues that since nobody likes to be rediculed, it works when the vice is tartuffe Question one A staged version of the play would be both hilarious and captivating but also incencing to some extent.... The facial expressions of the charaters would be varied depending on the role a person plays; those who are part of Orgon's family would appear perplexed at how gurllible Orgon is while tartuffe's confidence and pretetious timid would confound the audience....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Tartuffe by Moliere

The paper "tartuffe by Moliere" highlights that generally, Barbara Woshinsky places tartuffe's denouements in the context of classical dramatic theory and structure.... She presents tartuffe's ending as a surprise because of the events that happened at the end.... Emanuel Chill's article explores the religious and political pressure that resulted in the changes in tartuffe following its censorship and questions the impact of these transformations on the characters....
8 Pages (2000 words) Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us