StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Tort Law and Efficiency: The Hong Kong Context - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Social scientists need to carefully explore the emerging legal practices in the PRC. The close doctrinal analyses now dominating the discussion are worthy enterprises, but too much of this discussion is attuned to the process of passing laws and procedures rather than implementation and operating procedures…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Tort Law and Efficiency: The Hong Kong Context
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Tort Law and Efficiency: The Hong Kong Context"

Download file to see previous pages

It is easy in the abstract to distinguish between the formal dimension of law (the laws and procedures as they appear on the books, largely the product of legislative, bureaucratic, or appeal court rulings), the informal dimension (actual courtroom practice derived from informal understandings among judges, lawyers, and other frequent participants), and the customary dimension (the laws and procedures developed by business elites for their industries). American courts have specifically accepted the latter practices as legitimate. (Hooper) Both the formal and the informal dimensions may be less significant than the customary dimension.

Legal systems mould actual conduct in indirect and tangential ways. Most business elites do not expect to face one another in the courtroom, and studies of corporate behaviour in the United States demonstrate the reluctance of businesses to invoke the formal processes of the law. (Friedman 267-98) The legal system is seldom invoked, despite laments over the so-called litigation explosion in the United States. First, the formal process is slow, cumbersome, and costly. Most businesses want to settle their disputes quickly so that they can return to mutually profitable relationships.

Second, entering the courtroom expands the "scope of conflict" and poses serious threats to the actors. (Schattschneider 40) Not only are courtroom proceedings open to the public, but also the judge introduces a third set of social values and interests apart from those of the litigants. (Shapiro 5-8) Moreover, the courtroom is the domain of the legal professionals. Control over the dispute is handed over to advocates who are part of another system of values and perspectives.Prior to the industrialization of America and England in the early 19th century tort law had a limited scope primarily due to a lack of diversity and lack of quantity in tort cases.

However with large factories and railroads grew a complex relationship between employee, employer and consumer. Due to this it was necessary for the legal system to re examine lines of reasoning. Despite academics such as Friedman suggesting that the law became a tool for those few at the top of the new economic structure, it is more reasonable to concede that law was unable to stagnate in a period of such rapid development.Among those projecting the view of a law driven by economics are Horswitch and Friedman.

Central to their argument is that tort law reasoning was dramatically altered in both the United States and Great Britain to benefit the new technology to the detriment of individual justice. Horwitz in particular is adamant that the law was used as a subsidy for the new economy as taxes would be both obvious and a politically undesirable thing. However there is flaw in Horwitz's argument that; " though never entirely able to overthrow the regulatory assumptions behind the earlier law, these new doctrines nevertheless underlined a deep tendency .

to favour the active and powerful elements in American society " for the simple reason that there is little correlation between negligent law in the nineteenth century with any law preceding this, as it was a completely new area of law sparked by the unique situations that industrialization created. Therefore the old law could not be overthrown, as it never had to deal with tort cases of this nature. The new doctrines arose not as a

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Tort Law and Efficiency: The Hong Kong Context Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1517132-tort-law-and-efficiency-the-hong-kong-context
(Tort Law and Efficiency: The Hong Kong Context Essay)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1517132-tort-law-and-efficiency-the-hong-kong-context.
“Tort Law and Efficiency: The Hong Kong Context Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1517132-tort-law-and-efficiency-the-hong-kong-context.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Tort Law and Efficiency: The Hong Kong Context

Operating Systems and Networking

XYZ College faces competition from similar colleges in London that offer courses in law and finance such London Business School, King's College London, London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE), Imperial College London amongst others.... The logical grouping/subnetting of the overall network into smaller networks will optimize its efficiency and availability.... Currently, the college specialises in finance and law, has 3 campuses in Greater London and 5 study centres outside of London and has more than 200 staff members (including administration and academic staff) and over 2000 students in total across the country....
5 Pages (1250 words) Coursework

Work Pressure and Challenges among Medical Doctors in Private Clinic in Hong Kong

The quality of healthcare services offered by the hospitals as well as healthcare centers in hong kong is considered to be quite noteworthy by international standards.... hellip; Work Pressure and Challenges among Medical Doctors in Private Clinic in hong kong.... The quality of healthcare services offered by the hospitals as well as healthcare centers in hong kong is considered to be quite noteworthy by international standards.... The healthcare system of hong kong is considered to be almost similar with the best hospitals in Asian region such as Singapore, Malaysia as well as Thailand....
18 Pages (4500 words) Dissertation

Foundations of Tort

The primary focus of the Australian tort law reform focuses more on insurance premiums as opposed to the how deep taxpayers have to dig in their pockets to pay for the numerous lawsuits filed against the authorities.... Tort is a branch of private law, where a person suffers harm because of someone else's wrongful acts.... … Foundations of Tort Name Name of instructor Date Foundations of Tort Tort is a branch of private law, where a person suffers harm because of someone else's wrongful acts....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Construction procurement and legal framework for construction operations

The main aim is to maximize efficiency and consequently, minimize delay.... The comparison of the standard of building is outlined in the construction contract law.... hellip; mammoth 16 tort and Contract distinguished 18 Forms of Liability 19 Intention or negligence or the breach of statutory 19 Intention 19 Negligence 19 Breach of strict duty 20 ‘Reasonable' and ‘Reasonable man' 20 Introduction Construction simply refers building and assembling infrastructure....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

The Essential Elements of a Contract in a Business

In this context, there is no consideration as there is no price paid for the promise of the other party.... The law is relatively settled if the competent adults are bound by the terms of the contract.... Typically, courts will not weigh the adequacy of the consideration as long as the consideration is established to be sufficient, with sufficiency being defined as the meeting test of the law; adequacy is the subjective fairness or equivalence....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Work placement Module

My placement was served with Cheng Chan & Co, a solicitors firm in hong kong.... This Cheng Chan & Co is a private firm,, which mainly provided dealing with tort, criminal, contract, and family law cases.... He asked me few some questions on pertaining to tort and criminal law, such as which case to use or which statute to applies to a scenarioy....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Pros and Cons of Scientific Management

This is because the reported cases of this kind are increasing very fast and due to the fact that the principle underlying it is of wide and general application (Deakin & Markins 2008)In tort law, one can be responsible for the damages caused if he/she owed the claimant duty of care.... Terms of the contract: in the study and practise of law, different terms are usually employed to define critical aspects of law.... hellip; A contract is that legitimate accord between two or more parties and its law enforceable....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Effect of Globalization on Hong Kong Business

The author of the present research paper "The Effect of Globalization on hong kong Business" states that the ongoing process of Globalization and economic evolution in the industry will favour companies with strong brand equity, a loyal group of recurring customers and a proven record in innovation.... In a free-trade economy without the limitations of quotas, consumers and manufacturers in one area of the world seek for consumers and manufacturers in another part of the world, and with the international division of labour, greater efficiency can be achieved in catering the market needs and demands....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us