StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Evaluate Ethical Approaches - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Case 10: Laccaria and Eagle 1. Evaluate the case on Laccaria and Eagle from the four ethical approaches given below. (Write at least five sentences for each ethical approach): a. Deontological Deontological ethics concerns the rights of individuals. However, individuals do not act alone, but have duties to their fellow man, in general or personally…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.3% of users find it useful
Evaluate Ethical Approaches
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Evaluate Ethical Approaches"

Case 10: Laccaria and Eagle Evaluate the case on Laccaria and Eagle from the four ethical approaches given below. (Write at least five sentences for each ethical approach): a. Deontological Deontological ethics concerns the rights of individuals. However, individuals do not act alone, but have duties to their fellow man, in general or personally. .Deontological ethics could be considered closely linked to Kant, who believed that promoting the common good was good for everyone. The guiding criteria in deontological ethics is doing no harm—at the minimum, but ultimately helping people and leaving them better off , The choice in this instance using deontological ethics would be buying the Orista 45K.

It is unreliable, has poor service and the software need changes. However, it is good for the local economy and ultimately will help people. Of the other two, choices, the purchase of the Epsilon 4311 has neutral consequences, while the other, the Epsilon 45 is bad for the economy. b. Rights-Based Rights-based ethics is could be closely linked to the philosophy of formulated by John Locke emphasizing the rights of the individual and most importantly property-rights. This means that a person’s property should be protected against being compromised by another party’s action.

The individual is a person who as ‘contracted with’ or “bought into” this belief and thus has the overall responsibility to protect the property rights of others. Government may or may not protect these rights. We know in Laccaria, like many developing nations, software and hardware licenses are often ignored. Should Eagle be complicit with this illegal action and violation of property rights? The purchase of the Epsilon 45 is illegal and violation of licensing agreements. The other two options are both viable using this ethical logic.

Given that the Informatics Bureau advised purchasing the Epsilon 4311; this would probably be the tipping point for a decision over these two options. c. Virtue Ethics Virtue ethics is related to the characteristics or virtues of a person and their ability to act in a certain manner. A general statement that could characterize virtue ethics could be “Do unto others as you would like them to do unto you.”—in other words, “The Golden Rule.” Should we encourage ‘knock-offs” that damage patents and hard-earned intellectual individual rights?

Should we help people with their skills so that they will feel better about themselves? If you view the three options, the purchase of the Orista 45 is the best under virtue ethics d. Pragmatic Ethics The pragmatic approach is one where ethics are variable according to the situation. It could be said to be similar to the Utilitarian and the Machiavellian approach. In viewing the three options, the most likely candidate would be buying the Epsilon 45. Although they are considered ‘illegal’ by the government, there is a minor possibility that the company will be prosecuted.

Also, there are others who are purchasing this ‘knock-off’ so there will probably be not too much damage or ‘dis-utility” from these parties. Overall, what should the manager’s decision be? What would you do? The managers decision should be the purchase of the Orista 45 due that: 1)it is good for the local economy—which is a pragmatic decision if the company wants a long-term presence in the country and 2)it is less costly than purchasing the Epsilon 4311 with no apparent benefits to the local economy.

My decision would be to purchase the Orista 45K, although it is not a very good decision for the efficiency of the company. In developing nations, it is often not the most efficient, but what can benefit people that count. The option, which will be time consuming, will be to help the company with better service and improved software. In the short term, you may have ‘clunky’ software, but in the long term if you work with the difficulties, the company will have helped the company making the Orista 45K a better product and benefit the country.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Evaluate Ethical Approaches Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1426065-evaluate-ethical-approaches
(Evaluate Ethical Approaches Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/other/1426065-evaluate-ethical-approaches.
“Evaluate Ethical Approaches Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1426065-evaluate-ethical-approaches.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Evaluate Ethical Approaches

Evaluation Questions Assignment

Question 8 Evaluation approaches are many since they all make unique and helpful contributions to solving vital problems.... The makes the different approaches to evaluation liable since they all work together for the same purpose (Patton, 2001).... Question 5 Evaluators face tough ethical challenges.... Question 4 UMUC could also evaluate its courses by evaluating the schools physical space that encourage multiple and diverse learning and teaching programmes....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Normative Ethical Theories

As with any of the normative approaches to ethical thinking, such an approach necessarily disregards one theory or practice at the expense of its own interpretation of what is ultimately right or wrong.... As a means of understanding such a normative interpretation of ethics, this brief essay will seek to engage the reader on the topic of female genital mutilation (FGM) and provide a deontological viewpoint and ethical determination of the topic based upon ethical decision making that the deontological approach portends....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Ethics in Healthcare: Formulating the Dilemma

hellip; An ethical dilemma is a stance which involves a person to choose between two courses of action amongst which both are ethically adequate.... This verifies that without the help of proper ethical decisions and judgment skills, a nurse and the staff cannot cooperate in helping the patients or assisting themselves improve and become an active part of the society.... This ethical dilemma has various sides to be analyzed by Melissa as her professional values verify that she, rather follow and hunt down the case while along with her personal values....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

British Petroleum Company

Although there are several instances of violation of business ethics, one of the greatest scandals from gas and oil industry has been selected for evaluation with respect to two ethical theories.... The oil and gas industry has been considered for evaluation of ethical crisis in business because this industry is one of the essential sectors from the perspective of economic development and environmental impact.... Prior to discussing the spill and its ethical consequences, brief introduction regarding BP Plc has been provided in the following section (Hanson, 2014)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Handling Ethical Issues in Workplace

For employers to ensure that they are well prepared to handle any potential conflict that may arise in… However, in order to appropriately handle ethical issues in an organization, managers require cautious and steady approach to issues that are illegal and dangerous.... In this Handling ethical issues in workplace Handling ethical issues in workplace Values and morality-based dilemmas in workplace are very complex to handle when the workers are given the freedom of choosing what is wrong and right based on their principles....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment

Characteristics of Ethics in Business

This paper outlines possible alternatives to find a resolution to the ethical dilemma.... as an ethical perspective.... hellip; way to obtain an ethical framework that can be applied to real-life scenarios is by considering concepts and theories established by scholars on the subject.... Among the different theories that can simplify an ethical analysis are virtue ethics, egoism ethics, relativism, utilitarian ethical perspective, and the seven-step procedure for moral decision making....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Performative and Traditional Social Sciences - Definitions and Differences

That is to say, a particular theory is embedded in a particular body of knowledge possessing unique and systematic approaches and principles.... This paper, Performative and Traditional Social Sciences, discusses the definitions of PSS and TSS.... This essay follows and answers the queries asked by Yallop, de Vallejo, and Wright....
15 Pages (3750 words) Assignment

Counselor Ethical Boundaries and Practices

Some questions are ethically answered while some needs an understanding to the defined approaches (Pope & Vasquez, 2010).... The current paper "Counselor ethical Boundaries and Practices" examines the fact that as a successful client counselor, it is mandatory for the individual to know and understand the ethical boundaries described in counseling and client relationship.... It is through these ethical boundaries that the counselor is able to design strategies for the relationship so that an effective plan can be formulated for the process of counseling....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us