StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

A Philosophical Review of Nature's and Animal Rights - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Running Head: Environmental Ethics A Philosophical Review of Nature’s and Animal Rights Case Analyses Name Name of Professor Question 1 As stated by Gary Varner, biological interest has been defined by Feinberg (1974) as “an interest, however the concept is finally to be analyzed, presupposes at least rudimentary cognitive equipment…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.5% of users find it useful
A Philosophical Review of Natures and Animal Rights
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Philosophical Review of Nature's and Animal Rights"

Download file to see previous pages

In contrast, Tom Regan disputes that there is a difference between ‘having an interest in something’ and ‘taking an interest in it’ (Varner, 1998, 55), which then implies that domestic species, being mindless species, have innate biological interests. Regan thus defined biological interest in this way: “the two senses really are logically distinct: A being can be interested in something that is not in his interests, and something may be in a being’s interest despite the fact that he is not interested in” (Varner, 1998, 55).

This means that domestic species, having no conscious desires in any way, have biological interest of their own. Regan added that plants and objects can reasonably be thought to have biological interests, since both have intrinsic values in their own breed. On the other hand, Gary Varner (1994) argues that if all living things have biological interests, then it is implausible to prevent spoiling countless biological interests of others. Varner cited John Passmore’s passage to define biological interest: “the Jainist principle [of avoiding harm to all living things]… is far too strong.

This is the more obvious now that we are aware of the minute living organisms which everywhere surround us. In breathing, in drinking, in eating, in excreting, we kill. We kill by remaining alive” (as cited in Varner, 1998, 77). This implies that nonhuman animals and plants have biological interests of their own, but lose these biological interests when confronted with the biological interests of human beings. However, if domestic species do not have biological interests, it is still possible that they have inherent or intrinsic worth as shown by the arguments of Paul Taylor, Tom Regan, and Peter Singer.

First, according to Taylor (1981), to argue that a nonhuman animal has inherent worth is to assume that its interests [Taylor believes that domestic species have biological interests] merit the respect and thought of every moral agent. Moreover, the recognition of its interests has intrinsic value, to be realized as an objective and on behalf of the being whose interest it is. Taylor further argues that inherent worth is “not some mysterious sort of objective property belonging to living things that can be discovered by empirical observation or scientific investigation” (Taylor, 1981, 204).

Hence, to say that a domestic species, which would not exist without human interference, have no inherent worth is wrong since, according to Taylor, inherent worth cannot be determined by inductive reasoning or sense perception. Ultimately, Taylor (1981) believes that inherent worth is a “value that is ascribed to nonhuman animals and plants themselves, independently of their relationship to what humans judge to be conducive to their own good” (p. 204). Hence, with or without human interference, domestic species have inherent worth.

Similarly, Tom Regan states that “the presence of inherent value in a natural object is independent of any awareness, interest, or appreciation of it by any conscious being” (Varner, 1994, 26). Domestic species have inherent value, and it is equal to that of human beings. The lack of intellect or reason is not a justification to say that nonhuman animals do not possess inherent value. Likewise, Peter Singer claim that if a nonhuman animal has a particular feature, like biological inter

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Philosophical Review of Nature's and Animal Rights Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1428049-environmental-ethics
(A Philosophical Review of Nature'S and Animal Rights Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1428049-environmental-ethics.
“A Philosophical Review of Nature'S and Animal Rights Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1428049-environmental-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Philosophical Review of Nature's and Animal Rights

Mind - A Brief Introduction by Searle

The main reason that could be given to explain this might be based on the fact that the book goes beyond introducing the user to a philosophical subject that is very catching and this he does in a very clear and accessible language.... Mind: A brief introduction review It appears that according to Searle, the human mind could be delinked from its biological form and that this mind could occur as forming part of the nature itself.... Searle notes that the mind's philosophy is very unique when it comes to the pool of philosophical subjects....
4 Pages (1000 words) Literature review

Animal Rights

This literature review "animal rights" puts under the examination the following articles: “Why Worry About the Animals?... As such, it comes across as rhetorically authoritative and sets out to convince the reader that "the moral case rests both on the goods to be realized, the evils to be avoidedthereby, and on the duty to respect persons and to secure them in their natural and moral rights.... istorical information regarding the growth of animal welfare groups and the inclusion of feminist connections add weight to the argument in favor of abandoning practices that harm animals....
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

Is Consciousness the Same as a Soul

It occurs at many levels of animal life, though we cannot be sure of its presence in the simpler organisms, and it is very difficult to say in general what provides evidence of it”He says that the mind needs to be studied with subjectivity and objectivity attached to it.... This review "Is Consciousness the Same as a Soul?...
5 Pages (1250 words) Book Report/Review

Corporate Social Reporting

The author concludes that corporate companies are vouching for their accountability by presenting environmental and social reports.... Organizational transparency is increased by administrative reforms.... Stakeholders are provided information which influences the decisions and behavior of the firm....
12 Pages (3000 words) Literature review

The Moral And Ethical Base Of The Modern Society

Jonathan Glover is a philosopher and professor of ethics on the faculty of King's College, London.... The writer of the paper "The Moral And Ethical Base Of The Modern Society" discusses the main purpose of his book "Humanity: A Moral History of the Twentieth Century".... hellip; Glover heavily leans on the 19th Century German philosopher, Nietzsche, to propound his arguments....
10 Pages (2500 words) Book Report/Review

Human and Animals as Species

hellip; The 'Oxford Advanced Dictionary' does not define an 'animal' as a being/creation responsible to fulfill our dietary needs nor does it characterize an animal in a way that it should be treated ruthlessly or bred for our selfish nutritional desires, but the way it does define an animal is: “any living creature, including human beings” (Oxford Advanced Dictionary, P.... why do we feel it okay to kill an animal than a human being?...
7 Pages (1750 words) Literature review

Existence Perceive Essence

This book review "Existence Perceive Essence" analyzes three different existential literary works, namely, Albert Camus's The Stranger, Christopher Hitchens's Letters to a Young Contrarian, and Henry David Thoreau's Walden.... Moreover, the periods they lived or live are different and, hence, their world-views and philosophical interpretation of the purpose of human existence differ too....
13 Pages (3250 words) Book Report/Review

Ethics, Metaphysics, Pragmatism, and Their Individual Value

Applied ethics comprises is concerned with controversial matters in society such as human rights, environmental conservations, and animal rights.... Several fields of philosophical inquiry include Epistemology, Realism, Aesthetics, Cosmology, Theology, Logic, Ethics, Metaphysics, and Pragmatism (Figure 1)....
9 Pages (2250 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us