StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

An Outlook of Jonathan Haidts Social Intuitionist Theory - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "An Outlook of Jonathan Haidts Social Intuitionist Theory" highlights that various model theories have been devised to best illustrate and explain the processes of deriving a moral judgment. Two of the most influential theories include the Rationalist and Social Intuitionist Theory. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.4% of users find it useful
An Outlook of Jonathan Haidts Social Intuitionist Theory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "An Outlook of Jonathan Haidts Social Intuitionist Theory"

The classic rationalist theory of moral judgment presented a strong relationship between reasoning and cognition. Moral standards, an important basis of any moral judgment, are deduced to be knowledge structures (cognition) that are established through several reasoning activities (Darley 353 qtd. in Haidt 4). This theory suggests that every time humans derive a moral judgment, they are practically exhibiting a particular reasoning activity -- one that covers morality.

On the other hand, Haidt offers an alternative theory called the Social Intuitionist Theory which presents the moral judgment’s relationship to other significant factors -- one such factor is the human’s intuition. Under this theory, the relationship between the two is considered sequential. He supports this by claiming “that moral judgment is caused by quick moral intuitions, and is followed (when needed) by slow, ex-post-facto moral reasoning” (Haidt 5). Evidently, in terms of acknowledging the causal factor of a moral judgment, the first process to register and evaluate a circumstance (and then derive a judgment) is considered to have the closest relation or influence to the judgment made. Haidt’s theory claims intuition to be the first process our mind grasps in passing moral judgment.

An important difference between the rationalist and intuitionist theory is the interaction with other process factors aside from its perceived sequence. While the rationalist model focuses on reasoning and only emphasizes the participation of other processes with regard to this central concept, the social intuitionist model introduces the significant play of emotion, intuition, social influence aside from reasoning (Haidt 22). The low interrelation evident in the rationalist theory seems to neglect the capacity of the human mind processes to simultaneously act together and pose one prime mover -- reasoning. The high interrelation levels elicited by the social intuitionist theory illustrate the dynamism inherent in the human mind design.

The three supporting reasons of the theory include 1) interfering with reasoning; 2) ecological variation, and 3) consilience (Haidt 23-24). Since the intuitionist theory perceives the speed of reasoning as second best to intuition, interfering with reasoning significantly “affects the quality of the post hoc reasoning produced” (Haidt 23). The affected quality of the ‘reasoned judgment’ could invariably determine its reliability when it comes to passing a not-necessarily, socially-acceptable judgment. Ecological variation, in the social intuitionist theory’s context, predicts the distinguishable post hoc characteristic of the reasoning (Haidt 23).

This reason supports the predictable identity of reasoning as conditions vary. The last reason, the consilience, presents the theory as a well-founded study, covering findings and theories in social and developmental psychology, neuroscience, primatology and anthropology (Haidt 24). Thus, a wide array of fields supporting a single theory proves to have more merit than what is currently provided. Furthermore, this validates the significance of this theory for decision-makers. Haidt points out the need for a “correct understanding of the intuitive basis of moral judgment” to guide the decision-makers (3).

Conclusion
Passing a moral judgment is an important undertaking in making even the simplest task of decision-making. Thus, it is important to inculcate theories as these present intuitions aside from the commonly known reasoning factor. Acknowledging that a lot of other factors are at play in the human mind processes not just practically help us, but enables us to appreciate the unique human mind’s design.

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The emotional dog and its rational tail: A social intuitionist Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1587071-the-emotional-dog-and-its-rational-tail-a-social-intuitionist-approach-to-moral-judgement-by-jonathan-haidt
(The Emotional Dog and Its Rational Tail: A Social Intuitionist Essay)
https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1587071-the-emotional-dog-and-its-rational-tail-a-social-intuitionist-approach-to-moral-judgement-by-jonathan-haidt.
“The Emotional Dog and Its Rational Tail: A Social Intuitionist Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1587071-the-emotional-dog-and-its-rational-tail-a-social-intuitionist-approach-to-moral-judgement-by-jonathan-haidt.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF An Outlook of Jonathan Haidts Social Intuitionist Theory

Jonathan Edwards

His metaphysical theory possesses beauty as an aesthetic element in it and he considered it as an important feature of an entity (Jonathan Edwards: Biography).... jonathan Edwards jonathan Edwards, one of the most important philosophical theologians of America, has been famous as a philosopher as well as a missionary and is positioned among the greatest ever intellectual personalities of the nation.... Christian theology, Bible, Classics and ancient languages were the subjects of his childhood studies (jonathan Edwards: Biography)....
2 Pages (500 words) Research Paper

Contemporary ethical theory of Haidt

Intuitions, Reasoning and Moral Judgments Haidt introduced and formulated the social intuitionist model as an alternative to the rationalist model of moral thought.... Professor Course: Subject: Contemporary ethical theory of Haidt “Morality is the herd-instinct in the individual” Friedrich Nietzsche Introduction Haidt's theoretical project is to undermine the domination of rationalist models in the research on moral judgment.... The purpose the paper is to weigh the arguments of Haidt in favor of social intuitionism and counter-arguments by Pizarro and Bloom against each other to have better understandings of the ways moral judgment functions....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

A Review of the Intuitionist by Colson Whitehead

Name: Instructor: Institution: Date: A Review of the intuitionist by Colson Whitehead The intuitionist is a novel written by Colson whitehead and incorporates many themes.... He also shifts attention the issue of intuitionist versus empiricists of which Watsons was portrayed as an intuitionist.... She had strong views, and she is described in the book as ever right and an intuitionist.... The issue of intuitionist and empiricist is attributed to the way of doing things....
4 Pages (1000 words) Book Report/Review

Mass Media Effects on Violent Behaviour

The bulk of the content of that mass media has created is not designed to challenge or modify the social and political structure of a nation, even in one party state.... The purpose of the study "Mass Media Effects on Violent Behaviour" is to find out whether there is indeed a correlation between the frequencies of viewing videos with violence in content with the tendency of a person to manifest violent behaviour....
40 Pages (10000 words) Dissertation

Johnathan Swift and Laurence Sterne

'Gulliver's Travels' is the greatest work of jonathan Swift.... And it is a fact that these changes which can be economical, political, and social.... jonathan Swift created his works at the edge of the centuries what is often accompanied by great changes in the life of every society.... jonathan Swift partially belonged to the epoch of Enlightenment while Laurence Sterne was definitely the representative of this time....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Philosophy-Contemporary Ethical Theory4

Moore, an ethical intuitionist believed that good could be understood directly, through moral intuition, so that it is possible to say whether a moral statement is true or false.... Thus, meta-ethics goes further beyond ethical theories, to take into consideration what the concepts or terms used in ethics mean....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Theory and Practice in the Ethics Field

The paper "theory and Practice in the Ethics Field" examines the negative perspectives of morality.... For scholars of a given type of ethical theory, which is widespread in the Americas and Europe, and which is diversely referred to as 'intuitionism', 'non-naturalism, or 'objectivism', have often criticized their rivals for perpetrating the naturalistic fallacy (Foot, 2002, 51).... Specifically, this paper argues that naturalistic fallacy is essential, especially in the field of ethical theory and practice....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Contemporary Ethical Theory of Haidt

Haidt introduced and formulated the social intuitionist model as an alternative to the rationalist model of moral thought.... This paper ''The Contemporary Ethical theory of Haidt'' tells that Haidt's theoretical project is to undermine the domination of rationalist models in the research on moral judgment.... The purpose of the paper is to weigh Haidt's arguments in favor of social intuitionism and counterarguments by Pizarro and Bloom against each other to have better understandings of the way's moral judgment functions....
5 Pages (1250 words) Report
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us