StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Idea of Ideal Societies - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay investigates the idea of ideal societies. From the time of Plato, ancient thinkers believed that such a world order was possible if society was ruled by a wise, generous ruler. However, in practice, it often turned out that the pursuit of utopia required numerous blood sacrifices.
 …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.9% of users find it useful
Idea of Ideal Societies
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Idea of Ideal Societies"

IDEAL SOCIETY The idea of ideal societies or utopias have been with humans for as long as we have been around. People always believe that another better world is possible. However, throughout history the pursuit of utopias have led to human disasters. Politics, the process by which society is remodeled, is a complicated business and is best described as the art of the possible. Utopias are impossible and therefore extra-political means (usually killing large numbers of people) are required to try to create them. In the course of this essay, I will examine some thinkers' opinions on this issue, beginning with work in the 18th century. Plato was on of the first people to come up with the idea of an ideal state. He thought such a place could be created by letting philosopher kings, or those who love truth, govern everyone else. These people may have been wise, but they would clearly centralize power in their own hands. If they tried to direct the economy based on their own limited knowledge, they would cause serious problems. The notion of an all-knowing benevolent ruler who would create the perfect society is a fairy tale. This idea is sadly below someone like Plato's intelligence. But he was far from the last person to consider this issue. The Enlightenment was a remarkable time in human history. For many years, humans had lived in an intellectual or cultural “dark ages” where very little changed and people were wedded to their superstitions. Centuries went by and nothing really progressed. Instead of testing the world around them they simply accepted what clergymen or monarchs told them was true and left it at that. They didn’t test their limits; they just read old books and believed the facts in them. But this state of affairs could not last forever. There is an impulse, a curiosity, in humans that seeks sensible explanations. In the 17th century the Enlightenment began. Motivated by trade, the printing press, and a number of very significant intellectual leaders, this period of history saw a lot of the superstitions that guided people’s lives beaten back. Thinkers like Diderot, Voltaire, Adam Smith, and Thomas Jefferson revolutionized the way we think about the world and our place in it. Scientific innovation was also telling us more and more about our world, was exposing the fact that it was not run by ghosts and gods. Things began to change dramatically. People believed that a better world could be created through reason. The first utopians became famous. The power of science was very important to the Enlightenment and to its idea that utopias were possible. Science was the process people used to explain the world to themselves and it was really coming into its own. People like Galileo had shown us that the moon was not a perfect sphere and that the patterns of the other planets were not quite as perfect as once thought. People began to think that the world was knowable not by divine revelation but through scientific reasoning and measurement. They took up their slide rules and went to their labs to try to explain things. This was a positive thing. But some people also began to applying strict science to things like politics or race—concepts that can easily be distorted by so-called “reason.” There is a very real argument that reason led directly to the horrors of Communism, for example. People went too far: they believed everything could be determined by reason and that reason could create a utopia. This is a powerful argument. Indeed, the Communists thought man was perfectible through reason. They thought they could socially engineer the world: take control of everyone’s choices and personal lives and decide what was right and what was wrong. Even today there are countries that promote and follow this principle. For example, China’s one-child policy is an excessive product of reason. The solution to a problem is to hand over all power to the government to fix it based on the latest scientific thinking. This Chinese policy has not worked and instead has caused a great deal of suffering. The problem occurs when people think they can know everything or that they know best. They become egomaniacal and try to control everything. This may not be a direct product of the Enlightenment—for example, these principles were followed by clergyman as well—but it is a unique and horrible aspect of humanity. We can see this present in certain countries to this day: such as North Korea, China, and Cuba. They have little or no respect for human rights and believe they have stripped away all the traditions and myths that held people back. In fact, they have created unliveable countries for their people. The truth is that utopias are unachievable. In his famous article, Max Weber explains why he believes politics is the art of the possible. Very few single-issue or ideological people can win top office because politics is largely about building coalitions. If you take power and only respond to a small group of the population and refuse to compromise or be pragmatic whatsoever, it is unlikely you will last very long. Additionally, he writes about the qualities required to be a good stateman. Weber also talks about the state as having a monopoly on the use of force, an idea that comes from Hobbes. We see this as especially true today in police states such as North Korea and Iran. In the course of this essay Weber talks about how a state can control its people. He looks at the mechanism and function of a polity’s administration. Organized domination, which calls for continuous administration, requires that human conduct be conditioned to obedience towards those masters who claim to be the bearers of legitimate power. On the other hand, by virtue of this obedience, organized domination requires the control of those material goods which in a given case are necessary for the use of physical violence (Weber 3). This is part of a great debate in political science: how much control should people cede to their government? How much control should the state take in the best interests of its people? Plato thought if you just gave smart philosopher kings all the power they would always make the right moves. Indeed, some people believe in socialism and that everyone must be made equal by the government, the tall cut down and the short pulled up; others believe in a meritocracy where those people who have talent and work hard are rewarded for their labours. Is there a way to combine these two ideas? It might be possible, but it is unlikely that this “best of both worlds” approach would yield a society as productive as one that fully embraced individual freedom and capitalism. Thomas Hobbes, for example, is most famous for his book Leviathan, and he is a writer who Weber relies on for some of his thought about state control and sovereignty. In Leviathan, Hobbes argued that a “war of all against all” existed in nature and that people were mostly motivated by fear and distrust and that peoples’ motivations all conflicted with each other. The only way for order to prevail, Hobbes argued, would be through an absolute sovereign. Only a figure of immense power could guarantee the sorts of contracts people required with one another to live in peace. As Hobbes wrote, “The passions that incline men to peace, are fear of death; desire of such things as are necessary to commodious living; and a hope by their industry to obtain them” (Hobbes, 46). He believed that because people would do everything possible to preserve their lives and maximize their prosperity, there would be a constant battle between conflicting interests. In order to increase the order and prosperity of society as a whole, an absolute sovereign would have to make some minimum guarantees: namely, peace and the upholding of contracts. In this view of the world ethics must be imposed on human beings who are just animals red in tooth and claw and who live lives that are “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.” While there is certainly some truth to what Hobbes says regarding human beings, other political thinkers have questioned elements of his vision. Indeed there are several flaws in this theory, but it shows us that it is not possible for people to effectively work as a commune. That does not mean we need a dictator to control things, but it does mean we need a strong rule of law to protect individual freedoms. The rule of law is effectively the latter-day sovereign. It serves the same purpose: it protects contracts and business and prevents the seizure of power by socialist radicals. This is a point that Weber mostly agrees with, but he focuses a bit more on how the state is administered at the top: does it make a difference, for example, is the top members of the government have a stake in the state or if all power is centralized in the figure of the king or president? There is no easy answer to this question. Sources Hobbes, Thomas. Excerpt from Leviathan. In Pojman, Louis P. The Moral Life: An Introductory Reader in Ethics and Literature. New York: Oxford University Press, 2004. Weber, Max. “Politics as Vocation.” White, Joseph. “Uncle Sam enters the debate.” Wall Street Journal. June 23, 2009. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Idea of Ideal Societies Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
Idea of Ideal Societies Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1744802-ideal-society
(Idea of Ideal Societies Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
Idea of Ideal Societies Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1744802-ideal-society.
“Idea of Ideal Societies Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1744802-ideal-society.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Idea of Ideal Societies

The arguments of Plato to Butler

This is evident from the way she is able to brainstorm and come up with ideas (the idea of dreams) meant to redeem the ordinary people.... Martha after getting enlightenment, God proposes to use her in redeeming the world, where he comes with an idea of resurrecting her.... Therefore, both Plato's “Allegory of the Cave” and Butler's account “The Book of Martha” bear the same approach concerning how to impart their respective societies with the right knowledge meant to thrive or develop....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Role of Rationality in Forming Political and Economical Institutions

There are some commonalities between Marx's ideologies and the rational-choice idea of political attributes.... Similarly, economists suggest that Marxism idea of political attribute, like his capitalist economic attribute ideology, is, therefore, anchored in an individual rationality approach.... Instead of economic rationality and market strategies offering the foundation for premarket economy institutions, Polanyi suggests that organizational patterns are reflected in various traditional societies, (Miller 25)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Community Action Personal Health Paper

hellip; Even though such diseases are becoming more well-known and there is more support available for those with eating disorders, there will continue to be an increase in the incidence of them unless we as a culture start to change our ideas of what constitutes the "ideal" body. The activity I chose to carry out was to send a letter to the Calvin Klein clothing company.... I feel that they are a company who really exemplifies the trend towards "thin at all costs" - the idea that thin is an ideal which should be pursued regardless of the consequences....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Construction of Identity

Sapirstein (cited in BrainyQuote) had quoted, “The ideal mother, like the ideal marriage, is a fiction,” the ideal mother icon may seem to be non-existent.... As Dhar (1952) had pointed out that an ideal mother is one who “brings forth in her consciousness of purity and self sacrifice and that flow of divine bliss which lulls the whole creation in her lap.... ?? An ideal mother is a woman who brings to life a child whom she will rear, take care of, and love for the rest of her life....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Radical Idea of Marrying for Love

In the article “The Radical idea of Marrying for Love,” the writer, Stephanie Coontz revisits different cultures at different times in an attempt to show us that marriage and love have rarely gone parallel to each other, and people's attempt to combine the two started just… The work begins with some kind of a mock to the people's expectation of being strongly in love, a factor that is seen to contribute to a “happy marriage thereafter.... ?? According to Coontz, this is one of the most unrealistic ideas when it comes to marriage and The Radical idea of Marrying for Love In the article “The Radical idea of Marrying for Love,” the Stephanie Coontz revisits different cultures at different times in an attempt to show us that marriage and love have rarely gone parallel to each other, and people's attempt to combine the two started just recently....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Ideal Society

To establish an ideal society, people need to lead a disciplined life.... The different factors that are related to an ideal society, which comprise equality, justice and liberty are found to be interrelated with each other.... Apart from these factors, the role play by the police, respective governments and military also contribute in forming an ideal society.... With this concern, the essay intends to discuss about various important aspects that contribute in establishing an ideal society and also a comparison will be made amid these factors to acquire a brief understanding about the current criminal justice system prevailing in a society....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Family Is the Building Block

The aspect of a normal daily life will only develop if societies can share in the same sense of responsibility as noted amongst a majority of the people, something that works best in meeting the fragile and constant need for negotiation.... The main idea is to generate as much support for parents to continue taking care of their children while allowing them to instil discipline as required....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Rousseau and the Development of Democracy

"Rousseau and the Development of Democracy and Marx's Proletariatand" paper examines Rousseau's innovative approach to the idea of democracy in that while he believes that power should be within the sovereignty and Marx's system in which capitalism was the enemy of the working class.... This can be seen in Western societies where it is often the media that defines a problem and an informed choice by the public is not fully possible....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us