StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Platos Theory of the Psyche and Relate It with Managing Today - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Plato’s Theory of the Psyche and Relate It with Managing Today" paper states that Plato’s theory of the psyche has withstood the test of time. Even after two and half millennia of its first articulation, it remains an eminent source of wisdom and counsel to leaders in various fields…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.1% of users find it useful
Platos Theory of the Psyche and Relate It with Managing Today
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Platos Theory of the Psyche and Relate It with Managing Today"

Critically discuss Plato’s theory of the psyche and relate it with managing today: Plato is one of the most influential philosophers from the Hellenistic Age, whose ideas are still relevant to modern times. Business management as we know it today was not a preoccupation of Plato. For that matter, management of business enterprises under a capitalist framework is a modern phenomenon ushered in by the Industrial Revolution of late 18th century. But Plato was a polymath, who forwarded treatises on a range of subjects. Questions of what constitutes good governance under a monarch was a focus of his thought. When we look closely, there are many parallels between the structure of a kingdom and that of a business corporation. Both are more or less authoritarian institutions with a top-down power hierarchy. With the net worth of many Fortune 500 corporations is equivalent to the GDP of some nations, corporate houses are rightly referred to as ‘empires’ in management literature. Hence, although the thoughts of Plato and that of Peter Drucker are separated by two millennia, the former can be seen as a management guru in his own right. In particular, Plato’s speculations and assertions on the nature of human psyche have withstood the test of time and are a useful aid to modern managers. This essay will flesh out this thesis in detail. It is fair to state that of all ancient Greek philosophers, it was Plato, who defined and characterized the nature of the psyche in great detail. Plato was the one who “defined the abstract and the rational as equivalent to the moral good. He equated self-knowledge with self-restraint, and proclaimed that knowledge is virtue.... Lack of knowledge and the irrational, were equated with moral evil, and then, with madness.” (Buckley, 2001) For Plato, the ‘soma’ makes up the physical body, while the psyche is the “difference between a living body and a dead one: psyche is the Form of Man as living creature. The psyche is conceptually distinct from the body, which is thought of both as a prison and a tomb for the psyche.” (Management, Philosophy and Performance, PPT) According to Plato, the psyche is not made of substance and it is immortal. Plato divided human psyche into three components – the rational, affective and appetitive. In simple terms, examples of appetites or desires are thirst, hunger, etc. The ability to overcome the appetites is the function of the rational. And the appetitive, also called the Spirit is the moral compass as attuned by social norms. He defined conflict as a “struggle between the rational and the appetitive portions with each trying to enlist the affective portion on its side." (Buckley, 2001) For example, conflicts could arise in simple situation like these: I know it is wrong to lie, but can’t help myself in certain situations; I know it is morally corrupt to covet other men’s wives but I still end up looking at them lustfully; etc. It is a testimony to the amazing imagination and intellect of the great ancient philosopher that an analogous tripartite view of the mind was formulated by Sigmund Freud two millennia later. Plato’s three divisions of the psyche is similar to Freud’s structural model of ego, id and superego. “Thus we have an early tripartite view of the mind that echoes Freuds later structural model of ego, id, and superego. Plato saw mental illness as a consequence of an imbalance whereby the unbridled instinctual part gains the upper hand. Treatment is through the Platonic dialogue, a precursor of the psychoanalytic dialogue that brings the conflicting parts of the mind into harmony and reasserts control over the irrational part of the psyche. The philosophical dialogue, however, differs radically from the psychoanalytic dialogue, by attempting to discard the emotions, whereas in the analytic dialogue emotions are at the center of the treatment.” (Buckley, 2001) The similarities between Plato’s and Freud’s conceptions of the psyche are relevant to modern business management. This is so because Freudian psychoanalysis is well entrenched in Human Resources Management practice. Employee counseling, employee motivation, etc, draw heavily from modern psychology, especially Freud. And the Public Relations industry, in particular, is almost solely based on theory and practice of modern psychoanalysis. For example, contemporary consumer culture works by attracting customers with ego-stroking advertisement messages and by creating an illusory sense of security. This is nothing but adapting and exploiting theories of the psyche for commercial gain. (Russell, 2005) Plato understood that the human psyche is in constant exchange with the external social, cultural and political environment and these are “fundamentally shaped by the movement of meanings from polis to psyche and back again”. (Plato, 1957) The ecosystem of the business corporation has its own social, cultural and political content, thus enabling an application of Plato’s theory of the psyche to it. Plato works out one of the most insightful accounts of psychosocial degeneration ever formulated. Contemporary object-relations theorists, if they revisit the works of Plato, will find concurrence with his account of psychopathology. For Plato, the influence of polis on psyche and vice versa is largely unconscious. (Stevenson, 1987) According to him, most of human experience is illusory. In the classic Parable of the Cave narrated by Plato, “we are, unbeknownst to ourselves, strapped to a wall and forced to watch the projections of images onto the opposite wall which we mistake not only for reality, but for ourselves. We are, on this account, strangers to ourselves. But for Plato, there is therapeutic potential in pushing hard at contradictions inherent in the illusions themselves. Every image is a shadow, a distortion of something bearing more reality than it. In focusing on the distortion we can painfully and slowly work our way toward what the distortion is a distortion of. Once again Plato plants the hope of avoiding despair. (Buckley, 2001) The continued utility of Plato’s theory of the psyche to modern managers is illustrated by its perusal in management seminars and workshops. The one-week seminar conducted by North American Publishing Company is a good example. Titled ‘Plato arrives at publishing firm’, the seminar was run by John Wyatt, a professor of classics at the University of Chicago. For this event, more than 50 executives from the publishing industry, including editors and promoters attended hour-and-half long sessions that are steeped in content from Plato’s Protagoras and Aristotle’s Poetics. It might seem odd that Protagoras is allied with contemporary management issues in the publishing industry. But the organizers of the event firmly believed that “the classics would benefit, even inspire, editors and promotional copywriters.” ("Plato Arrives at Publishing," 1997) Seminars of this sort are by no means an exception, as similar events are organized across the year. For example, seminars about ancient Greek philosophers’ views on the art and scope of writing and deductive logic are being held. Even matters of corporate social responsibility and partnership with local community are being discussed. Similar to how pupils at Athenian libraries would have debated and discussed, attendees of modern management seminars are also discussing “clarity and immediacy in communication, the notion of a sublime piece of work, and purpose and meaning in human activity...The seminars also proved that ivory-tower concepts can find hard-nosed applications in the business world.” ("Plato Arrives at Publishing," 1997) Since the beginning of the industrial revolution, the advancement in technology has accelerated the process of automation. Today, the manufacturing sector is quite small compared to the services sector. The pool of knowledge workers, aided by Information Technology are growing at a rapid pace. And here too, we find the theories of Plato quite useful. To illustrate, “For more than two millennia, trying to understand the nature of knowledge has been the key of philosophers and scientists. Seven key groupings can be seen. The discussions on knowledge start with the work of Plato and Aristotle. Plato, in the Theaetetus, one of his Socratic dialogues (Plato, 369BC) tries to answer the question "What is knowledge?" He proposes three key concepts: "Knowledge is perception"; "Knowledge is true belief"; and "Knowledge is true belief with an account". (Grant & Grant, 2008) Even the process of knowledge creation and transfer prevalent in management practice today has parallels to Plato’s ideas on knowledge. For example, the three stage evolution from apprentice to journeyman to master propounded by Plato is very similar to how an apprentice graduates through skill levels in the workplace. This model holds true for both cognitive and practical skills. (Grant & Grant, 2008) Hence, in conclusion, it is fairly clear that Plato’s theory of the psyche has withstood the test of time. Even after two and half millennia of its first articulation it remains an eminent source of wisdom and counsel to leaders in various fields. Business corporations, which are the most visible symbols and dominant institutions of current times, can greatly benefit by heeding to Plato’s thoughts, especially those related to his theory of the psyche. (Lynch & Cruise, 2006) That there are parallels between Plato’s tripartite view of the human psyche to that of Freud’s conception of the mind is testimony to the former’s veracity and importance. While a discussion of Plato in modern corporate lounges might see out of place, it is the right approach to solving key management issues. References Buckley, P. (2001). Ancient Templates: The Classical Origins of Psychoanalysis. American Journal of Psychotherapy, 55(4), 451+. Grant, K. A., & Grant, C. T. (2008). Developing a Model of Next Generation Knowledge Management. Issues in Informing Science & Information Technology, 5, 571+. Lynch, Thomas and Cruise, Peter. (2006). Handbook of Organization Theory and Management, The Philosophical Approach, Second Edition, Published by Francis & Taylor. Stevenson, Leslie. (1987). Seven Theories of Human Nature, Second Edition, Oxford University Press. Pp. 71 – 84. Management, Philosophy and Performance – PowerPoint Presentation, MGT210, Platonism: Leading from the Psyche. Plato. (1957). Platos Theory of Knowledge: The Theaetetus and the Sophist of Plato (F. M. Cornford, Trans.). New York: Liberal Arts Press. Plato. (1961). The Collected Dialogues of Plato, Including the Letters (E. Hamilton & H. Cairns, Eds.). New York: Pantheon books. Plato Arrives at Publishing Firm; Classics Professor Shares Greek Ideals on Critical Thinking and Creativity with Business Editors. (1997, October). Folio: The Magazine for Magazine Management, 16, 25+. Russell, D. (2005). Plato on Pleasure and the Good Life. Oxford, England: Oxford University Press. Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Platos Theory of the Psyche and Relate It with Managing Today Essay, n.d.)
Platos Theory of the Psyche and Relate It with Managing Today Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1784012-critically-discuss-platos-theory-of-the-psyche-and-relate-it-with-managing-today
(Platos Theory of the Psyche and Relate It With Managing Today Essay)
Platos Theory of the Psyche and Relate It With Managing Today Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1784012-critically-discuss-platos-theory-of-the-psyche-and-relate-it-with-managing-today.
“Platos Theory of the Psyche and Relate It With Managing Today Essay”. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1784012-critically-discuss-platos-theory-of-the-psyche-and-relate-it-with-managing-today.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Platos Theory of the Psyche and Relate It with Managing Today

Plato's Forms: Do They Exist

Consider any property of a thing; do not relate it with that thing and think it by itself and one would be considering a form.... Plato's theory of Forms is piece of his beliefs that help a person to understand the manner that things are present in this material world; in the course of this World of Forms, one is forced to take in that objects are not always the way they come into sight to be in the material world, but in the World of Forms they are in their indispensable forms....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Plato: Justice Both Ways

27- 347 BCE) is one of the most famous Greek philosophers who is most widely read even today.... He was a student of Socrates and often cast his philosophical writings in the form of dialogue between Socrates or other real or imaginary speakers.... In his later writings… (Plato,) His most famous work was named “The Republic” in which he describes that the ideal state of Good exists as an independent reality and that all human beings should aspire towards Plato Justice both ways Order No: 177656 No: of pages: 2 Premium 6530 Plato (c....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Means of Social Organization by Plato

Plato, who was a student of Socrates, pulled together the ideas of his mentor and Pythagoras to combine them with his own response to what he'd seen of the world to develop his theory of Forms.... To help explain his theory of Forms, Plato developed what is today referred to as the Allegory of the Cave.... His Allegory of the Cave and theory of Forms introduces interesting ideas of exploration regarding what is right and good.... It is through Plato that we gain the knowledge of Socrates, perhaps one of the ancient world's most famous philosophers but what were the ideas of Socrates and which were the ideas of Plato remains a mystery today....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Plato's educational plan

Lastly, most successful members of the society participate in managing city as an apprentice for a final period of fifteen years.... Specifically, this paper will discuss some of the aspects of educational theory presented by Plato, and will endeavor to analyze it with respect to contemporary public education system in the United States....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Allegory of Den by Plato

For example, in American society, elementary schools relate to Plato's cave because most of children from grade 1 to 6 lack information about life.... For example, in American society, elementary schools relate to Plato's cave because most of children from grade 1 to 6 lack information about life.... These areas relate to Plato's cave because people lack freedom....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Platos Ethics: Aristotle, David Hume, Bertrand Russell, John Stuart Mill, and Richard Dawkins

avid Hume Hume is famous for his empiricist theory of the mind which asserts that reason is a slave of passions; moral distinctions are not derived from reason; moral distinctions are derived from moral sentiments; and that virtues are either natural or artificial....  In the paper “Plato's Ethics” the author analyzes Plato's issue of ethics....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Platos Theory of Human Nature

Socrates refutes Thrasymachus view and the opinions of the other interlocutors by claiming that the interest of every individual is Plato's theory of Human Nature Plato's theory of Human Nature Plato's defense of justice portrays his perception of the human nature.... The paper describes Plato's theory of human nature and describes how he succeed and ways he failed.... It then tries to relate Plato's theory of human nature with his theory of politics....
2 Pages (500 words) Article

Plato Is the Epitome of Western Science and Philosophy

As a matter of fact, the genesis and evolution of Western philosophy starts with Plato before graduating to later thinkers who followed and built on the foundations he laid.... Together with Socrates and Aristotle, who was his… To illustrate his brilliance, it is often said that in his thoughts received little to no criticism because few philosophical minds could rival his....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us