StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of Erikson's Stage of Initiative Vs Guilt - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
 This paper focuses on the ‘initiative versus guilt stage. Further to discussing this stage in depth, this paper highlights the importance of investigating studies pertaining to children especially in the development stages, upon evaluation of the studies on this topic…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.3% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Analysis of Erikson's Stage of Initiative Vs Guilt"

Analysis of Erikson's Stage of Initiative Vs Guilt Psychologists often differ on a number of issues, and psychoanalysis is no exceptional. The stages that a child undergoes right from the infant stage to the adulthood are a center of disagreements. Even though there is an agreement of the process one goes through, some of the challenges encountered and their impact in the future is the real bone of contention. Erik Erikson’s theory of the stages one follows from the infant stage to adulthood has been discussed and critiqued severally. According to Erikson, humans go through certain stages in the psychosocial development and each has challenges, which ought to be overcome failure to which there is a likelihood of hardship in the future. The theory has many stages, but in this paper, the focus will be on the ‘initiative versus guilt stage. Further to discussing this stage in depth, this paper will highlight the important of investigating studies pertaining to children especially in the development stages, upon evaluation of the studies on this topic. Crisis will occur at every stage of the development, and they will be both psychological and social-related. According to Erikson, each development stage has crises, which ought to be overcome by the individual in that stage. The crises emanate from the psychological need of a particular individual, and tend be conflict with society’s needs hence ‘social. When an individual successfully overcomes them, there is a sense of significantly healthy personality. In addition, there is an acquisition of the very essential virtues. For instance, in the ‘initiative versus guilt stage which occurs at the ages of between 3 and 5, a child who is successful will have a strong virtue of purpose. Conversely, a child who fails in this stage will not only have a weakness on the virtue of finding purpose; they will struggle in completing the other phases (Tsao, 2010). The ‘initiative versus guilt’ stage is often characterized by vigorous actions on the side of children and there is a tendency by parents to see the former’s actions as aggressive. However, these activities are imperative to this stage and the parents have to allow the process to go on unhindered (Capps, 2013). In addition to showing the said signs, children will also play regularly, interact with others and even initiate activities and games that showcase their creativity. These activities, which usually carried out in the company of other children, offer them the much-needed opportunity to develop interpersonal skills. If the children are given ample time and space to engage in these activities, they tend to develop a strong sense initiative. Besides, they start feeling they are capable of leading and influencing others, thus the need to ensure children are interrupted, rushed and reprimanded while in this stage. Where the parents fail to recognize the importance of allowing the children to grow as per the demands of the stage, there is a great amount of guilt engulfing a child. If after attempting a particular activity, a child is portrayed by the parent as foolish, the child will shrink and this will hinder the ability to overcome the challenge. Moreover, the child will lack the enthusiasm to embrace creativity, which is essential at this stage besides crippling the development of the interpersonal skills (Berger, 2007). Guilt emanates from the impression created by the parent’s actions that whatever a child is doing is not relevant or is bad. Consequently, it become almost impossible for a child to view such actions from any other angle except the one portrayed by the parent. In the theory, Erickson states that the major requirement for this stage is the parent’s decision to give the child as much independence as possible. The reason for the recommendation is that the child will often ask questions some of which light sound trivial or even nuisance. This occurs because at this stage the child thirsts for knowledge. Any mistake by the parent to show the child that questions asked are either stupid or nuisance, the child might resort becoming a follower rather than take initiative. In addition, a child might take on some initiative that pose danger to them, and the normal thing for a parent will be to stop the child. However, the harm is not more in stopping the child but in the methods, tactics and tones used. Notwithstanding the above assertions, guilt is a necessity in this stage as it teaches the toddler a sense of self-control. Again, where the parents fail to restrict the independence, the child might not understand the limits of their initiatives. As a result, this will inhibit their capability to grow in other stages. It is for this reason that parents have to balance the importance of self-initiative by parents and the necessity of guilt. An excess of either will lead to an unbalanced life, thus creating a hurdle in the next stage. In contrast, where balance is achieved, purpose is realized, and the next stage will be evidenced by tremendous tenacity and impetus by the child to over whatever crises that characterize it. Evaluation While this theory offers a nutshell of what to expect as a parent when a child reaches this stage, it is lacks clarity on the other issues likely to affect children. For instance, it was reported that while not all children are susceptible to the environmental adversity such as marital, financial or emotional stress, these were “linked to social emotional behavior problems and cognitive deficits” (Obradovic, Bush & Stamperdahl, 2010 p.270). That is to say, whereas the issues going on externally might not universally affect the children, a significant portion of them is affected. The fact that Erikson’s theory does not adequately addresses the issue means there is a deficiency, hence the need to carry out further research on social development stages. In other words, it is imperative to ascertain if external factors do indeed influence the social development of children. More weaknesses in this theory is that it does offer the balance that is required for parents to avoid overdoing their role of ensuring a child’s safety is well catered. Though the study states that guilt is important to help a child understand how self-control is cultivated, it lacks the methodology to apply in ensuring balance. Therefore, it is vitally important further research studies are carried out to establish how a parent could balance their role and the independence a child needs. Where this is not achieved, Tsao (2010) argued that there is a possibility of a lack of balance, which will inadvertently lead to struggles by the child in the next stage. Despite having these weaknesses, the study could also offer very important lessons to the parents on how to handle their children upon reaching this stage. While the study is not comprehensive in a number of areas, it offers a glimpse of what parents should expect their children to exhibit. Furthermore, it prepares the children on the approach to have when a child’s activity is dangerous. Instead of being extremely angry, a parent could gently explain the risks of undertaking certain initiatives without using demeaning, insulting or reprimanding tones. In essence, the study provides parents with an overview of how a child is likely to behave, and how their trends ought to be reciprocated. Nonetheless, the study fails in offering a remedy on how parents ought to ensure external adversity do not affect the children or how to respond. Recommendations Clearly, this study has offered some vital information on the stages humans undergo, and this important to help children in every stage. With this knowledge, parents and guardians can raise children in full understanding of their expectations. Concerning the approach of the study, it can be described as one done in a good way, albeit with a few limitations. As noted, there is a need to carry out further research in the topic of social development, particularly in the ‘initiative versus guilt’ stage because some underlying issues are yet to be addressed adequately. The reaction of children to the environmental crises, which might be facing their parents, ought to be addressed. In addition, the study on whether it is the tone or the entire action of restricting a child’s initiative that results in guilt ought to be addressed further. Overall, the study offers some precious lessons on how a child behaves in this stage, but it is imperative to conduct further research to have a holistic picture of the stage. References Berger, K. (2007). Study guide to accompany The developing person through the life span, 7th edition. New York: W. H. Freeman. Capps, D. (2013). Erik H. Erikson’s Young Man Luther: A Classic Revisited. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 64(3), 327-329 Obradović, J., Bush, N., Stamperdahl, J., Adler, N., & Boyce, W. (2010). Biological Sensitivity to Context: The Interactive Effects of Stress Reactivity and Family Adversity on Socioemotional Behavior and School Readiness. Child Development, 81(1), 270-289. Tsao, C. (2010). Successful Resolutions: Erik Erikson's Eight. Development and Psychopathology, 34(4), 290-291. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analysis of Erikson's Stage of Initiative Vs Guilt Essay”, n.d.)
Analysis of Erikson's Stage of Initiative Vs Guilt Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/psychology/1694254-a-discussion-on-the-topic-of-erik-h-eriksons-stage-of-initiative-vs-guilt-and-the-importance-of-investigating-research-studies-of-children-at-this-stage-of-development
(Analysis of Erikson'S Stage of Initiative Vs Guilt Essay)
Analysis of Erikson'S Stage of Initiative Vs Guilt Essay. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1694254-a-discussion-on-the-topic-of-erik-h-eriksons-stage-of-initiative-vs-guilt-and-the-importance-of-investigating-research-studies-of-children-at-this-stage-of-development.
“Analysis of Erikson'S Stage of Initiative Vs Guilt Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1694254-a-discussion-on-the-topic-of-erik-h-eriksons-stage-of-initiative-vs-guilt-and-the-importance-of-investigating-research-studies-of-children-at-this-stage-of-development.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Erikson's Stage of Initiative Vs Guilt

Erikson and Post-Freudian Theory

The purpose of this research "Erikson and Post-Freudian Theory" is to conduct an analysis of two popular psychological theories regarding the self-identity: Erikson and Post-Freudian.... Identity issues had a great impact on his life and formed the basis of his developmental stage theory.... The life cycle of human development is dependent on every development stage.... erikson's theories were greatly influenced by Freudian training as well as his quest for personal identity....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Training Objective

Autonomy versus doubt marks the second stage where children develop firm trust and attempt to explore the next stage is of initiative versus guilt where children exercise initiative inn activities by interaction with other children.... Children conjure their imaginations as being wrong and make choices that may not result to guilt.... The first stage is about trust and mistrust children make distinction between themselves and others.... The fourth stage is of inferiority versus industry....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Psychological Schools of Thought

nbsp;… The essay shall focus on two schools of thought that are both considered as developmental theories; these are erikson's school of thought and Freud's school of thought.... (Flax, 2003)Comparison of Freud and erikson's schools of thoughtAs it has been stated earlier, Freud was identified with the theory of psychoanalysis.... The latter author was largely responsible for the theory of psycho-social development while the former author was well known for his theory of psycho analysis....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Psychological Theories of Individual Development

The person's inherent analysis of his life, this becomes the main focus of humanistic psychology.... The newborn stage, as he suggests, is delineated to trust vs.... Divided into eight stages, he argues that for every stage man has definite goals and desires to master to be able to overcome various personal conflicts.... This is particularly so in Western societies where this stage is vital in the formation of a person that could lead to his character throughout his life....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Comparative Analysis of Two Personality Theories

This report "Comparative analysis of Two Personality Theories" contrasts the Theories of Personality of Erik Erikson's Psychosocial Development and Abraham Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs.... His approach was more holistic in nature thus extending the stage concept throughout a certain life span, otherwise known as the life span approach.... ccording to Erikson, stage one is developed within the early stages of life or during infancy.... Parenting, according to his theory is the main source of stage one's development....
7 Pages (1750 words) Report

Theoretical Analysis of My Psychosocial Development

The author of the "Theoretical analysis of My Psychosocial Development" paper analyzes him/herself since there is hardly anyone whose life journey the author knows as well as he/she knows my own.... The author can trace his/her earliest consciousness back to the time when he/she was three years old....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Life Stage Theory of Erikson

"Life stage Theory of Erikson" paper focuses on Erikson's theory that has eight different stages.... Erik emphasis on the adolescent period because he believed that it was an important stage in the growth and development of an individual's identities (Ramkumar).... The outcome of every stage results in developed life skills, functions, and abilities to do different things within an individual capacity....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Analysis of Psychosocial Development

For example, as a child we are more “centric” as we are more preoccupied with the satisfaction of our whims being in the stage of “id” or in the stage where our acts are dictated primarily by instincts.... analysis of Psychosocial DevelopmentUnderstanding the development of a human being from a scientific view that includes not only the physical development but also its psychosocial development is a very interesting and engaging topic because it also enables me to understand the process of how I became into being as well as others....
2 Pages (500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us