StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of the Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Philosophers - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Analysis of the Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Philosophers" paper links excerpts from the script Fight Club and the philosophies of John Calvin. The major link between the two will be demonstrated through the moral scruples of the cartoon Calvin and Hobbes…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
Analysis of the Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Philosophers
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of the Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Philosophers"

The Characters Tyler and Jack In Fight Club And Calvin and Hobbes (The Philosophers and the Cartoon Characters Based Upon Them): A Comparison Analysis of literature in a creative way requires some seriousness of thought. Here it will be attempted to link excerpts from the script Fight Club and the philosophies of John Calvin and Thomas Hobbes. 

The major link between the two will be demonstrated through the ethical and moral scruples of the cartoon Calvin and Hobbes, which will be described further in detail later on herein. The characters in Fight Club are supposed to mirror Calvin and Hobbes, and Calvin and Hobbes are supposed to mirror the philosophers John Calvin and Thomas Hobbes. 

 One of the more amusing scenes in Fight Club is where Tyler and Jack are at a restaurant having a conversation about consumerism. This is a snippet from Tyler’s end of the conversation: “Its a blanket, just a blanket. Now why guys like you and I know what a duvet is? Is this essential to our survival? In the hunter-gathered sense of the word? No. What are we then?... Right. Were consumers.  Were by-products of a lifestyle obsession. Murder, crime, poverty— these things dont concern me. What concerns me is celebrity magazines, television with five hundred channels, some guys name on my underwear. Rogaine, Viagra, Olestra.”1 If one compares the main characters in Fight Club, Tyler and Jack, to the cartoon characters Calvin and Hobbes (which were based retrospectively on the philosophers John Calvin and Thomas Hobbes), one can see the obvious links between the two media on the subjects of consumerism, American culture, and the American dream. “Calvin and
Hobbes [was] a comic strip nationally syndicated from 1985 to 1995.” Here it will be examined that “…the content found in Calvin and Hobbes to determine underlying
messages concerning ethics and values.”2 Consumerism, in Fight Club, is seen as an obsessive quality. What really seems to “matter” is money. The American mindset is not focused on what the rest of the world is concerned about—survival. Rather, it is concentrated on name-brand products and who has the biggest toys in the sandbox. This points to an overall problem with the American cultural way of thinking. In general, Americans place too much emphasis on success by how much money one makes, what kind of car one drives, and so on and so forth. The fact is, Americans are driven by an inward-directed fear that they will not be financially successful and that is what drives Americans to be workaholics. What the cartoon strip Calvin and Hobbes is really trying to chip away at is the fact that our values system as Americans is misplaced. While Calvin is a boy focused on playing and doing the things a boy likes to do, his friend and stuffed tiger Hobbes is just along for the ride—much like Tyler and Jack in Fight Club. Tyler, like Calvin in Calvin and Hobbes, is the sort of mastermind of the entity that is Tyler and Jack. Like Calvin has Hobbes as his rapt audience, Tyler has Jack at his whimsy while they are hanging out. Tyler is ready to spout off his ideas about consumerism which consume him—usually with little or no protest coming from Jack. Tyler takes the stage, and is completely emotionally invested in becoming the star of the show. Likewise, Calvin in the Calvin and Hobbes cartoon strip is a rather industrious sort of fellow, who takes over the show and has a consumeristic approach in his dealings with Hobbes. He is out to exploit Hobbes as a friend mainly because he can. Hobbes, since he is a stuffed tiger, is helpless at the whim of Calvin. Similarly, this mirrors the philosophical bent and sheer brain power that Calvin the theologian and philosopher would have probably had over Hobbes the philosopher in real life were the twain to meet. For, Calvin has an excellent train of thought which would most likely outsmart Hobbes any day. For, although Hobbes may have been a great mind with regard to politics, Calvin would be able to take the moral high ground and deduce whether certain actions were sinful or not. This is where Hobbes and Calvin differ and contrast sharply. There is an underground fight club which Tyler created in order to retroactively fight consumerism. It was also created in order to be a springboard for Project Mayhem. Additionally, the fight club provided solace for Space Monkeys seeking a way to channel their frustrated energies. Tyler pontificates further on his feelings about the way things are going in the United States and basically with regard to American culture in general. He says: “Man, I see in fight club the strongest and smartest men who have ever lived. I see all this potential—God damn it, an entire generation pumping gas and waiting tables;  theyre slaves with white collars. Advertisements have them chasing cars and clothes, working jobs we hate so we can buy shit they dont need. We are the middle children of history, man. No purpose or place. We have no great war, or great depression. Our great war is a spiritual war. Our great depression is our lives. Weve all been raised by television to believe that one day well all be millionaires and movie gods and rock stars -- but we wont. And were learning slowly that fact. And were very, very pissed off.”3 Here, we can see that Tyler is again becoming the center of attention. However, this is now not a focus on consumerism but on American culture. Calvin, in the cartoon Calvin and Hobbes, is an example for the masses. In one cartoon, Calvin is trying desperately to get some homework done and he asks Hobbes for help. Hobbes gives him the wrong answer, but Calvin hopes he will get points for “creativity.”4 In Tyler’s case, what seems to be the essence of Tyler’s speech is the lack of values America has. Calvin trying to cut corners on his homework is a prime example of the idea that “if I can’t do it, I can always find someone who will help me get the proper answer,” a form of learned helplessness. It is of singular importance for the viewer of Fight Club to realize that the working-class poor have little to hang on to when their lives and dreams are slowly being crushed in the gears of corporate America. It is necessary for readers of Calvin and Hobbes to understand that they just won’t get a free ride, either. Americans have to reevaluate their ideas of what they think matters in life, which means having realistic goals and thinking seriously about why one is here on the planet. Is one born to wait tables? Perhaps so—but if that is the case, it can be done with dignity, and there is more to that person’s life than just waiting tables. Also, there is this ingrained idea that we as Americans deserve the best because we are Americans, which is a faulty concept. That person may value things in life that are outside work which make life more fulfilling. John Calvin certainly would have placed a high value on the merits of hard work. While Hobbes may not have stressed that fact as much, he probably would have agreed that Americans have to examine their own inner motivation for doing things, which is not a common task to be doing nowadays. Calvin and Hobbes as a cartoon reaffirms in words what Fight Club shows and what these two philosophers would have thought—that our values must change. In the Fight Club, one of the obvious messages is that the American dream is fomented by the fact that so many people have a standard that they are willing to live up to which is unattainable. John Calvin, a strict theologian,5 probably would have rejected the notion that we all need to have large refrigerators, drive an SUV, and have remote-controlled TiVo. As for Thomas Hobbes, the “father of modern political thought,” he had a critical view of American scholastic thought.6 Hobbes, as the foil to Calvin, probably would have been in favor of all kinds of progress and competition that one sees in the ideal of the American dream: living in a large house with a walk-in closet and a white picket fence, owning a dog, and having 2.5 children. Hobbes would “…not think that we are basically or reliably selfish; and he [would] not think we are fundamentally or reliably rational in our ideas about what is in our interests.”7 Although it seems that Hobbes would disagree with the fact that people are totally immersed in their own selfish pursuits, it may be true that one should be unsure if the American dream would be something that he or she really wants, if that is the desired goal. Calvin the philosopher, on this point, would probably be rather base in his reaction and say that people are in fact sinful and would therefore flock to whatever their own needs are primarily. He would probably agree with Hobbes on the fact that people do not ultimately know what they really want, however. Calvin and Hobbes (both the philosophers and the cartoons) are like Tyler and Jack in that they give and they take with regard to various philosophical viewpoints. Calvin the boy and Tyler are the controlling and dominant personalities. Meanwhile, Hobbes the tiger and Jack are both at the mercy of their own counterparts. Like the philosophers Calvin and Hobbes, Tyler and Jack are both at each others’ counterpoints from a philosophical standpoint. While John Calvin is aloof, calculating, and cold in his estimations of people (as is Tyler), Hobbes is more of an unassuming philosopher with a laid-back personality, like Jack. On the following points, both Calvin and Tyler, like Hobbes and Jack, reflect the same values: consumerism, the American culture, and the American dream. While Tyler points out the faults of American society, Calvin is quick to exploit those faults. Hobbes and Jack are merely pawns to fomenting the ideas of their foils Calvin and Tyler. REFERENCES Coleman, Alisa White. "Calvin and Hobbes: A Critique of Societys Values.” Journal of Mass Media Ethics: Vol. 15, 2000. . Retrieved 20 April 2009. The Internet Encylopedia of Philosophy. John Calvin. . Retrieved 20 April 2009. The Internet Encylopedia of Philosophy. Thomas Hobbes. . Retrieved 20 April 2009. Uhls, Jim. Fight Club: The Final Screenplay, Part 3 (Based on the Novel by C. Palahniuk). 2008. 20 April 2009. . Uhls, Jim. Fight Club: The Final Screenplay, Part 1 (Based on the Novel by C. Palahniuk). 2008. 20 April 2009. . Welcome to Uffen.Org Web Site. Calvin and Hobbes Web Page. http://uffen.org/c_hobbes5.html. Retrieved 20 April 2009. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Assignment, n.d.)
The Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Assignment. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1723193-literary-analysis-of-the-link-between-the-book-fight-club-and-philosophers-thomas-hobbes-and-john-calvin
(The Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Assignment)
The Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Assignment. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1723193-literary-analysis-of-the-link-between-the-book-fight-club-and-philosophers-thomas-hobbes-and-john-calvin.
“The Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Assignment”. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1723193-literary-analysis-of-the-link-between-the-book-fight-club-and-philosophers-thomas-hobbes-and-john-calvin.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of the Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes the Philosophers

How Multiple Identities Were Portrayed in the Film Fight Club

This is fully exhibited in fight club when Jack fights to put off the bombs set by Tyler for the destruction of the credit card companies.... The focus of the paper "fight club" is on dissociative identity disorder, a mental illness in which a person assumes two personalities, memory lapse or impairment that causes extraordinary forgetfulness to an individual, substance abuse, other medical conditions, or seizures, brain problems only.... The movie, fight club, clearly shows how D....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Historical Philosophers namely Hobbes, Paine and Plato

This report "Historical Philosophers namely Hobbes, Paine and Plato" analyses the political theories each of the philosophers Hobbes, Paine, and Plato have written throughout history and try to link these political theories with contemporary theories and politics.... Hobbes is one of the most influential historical political philosophers.... His most influential work that hobbes wrote is Leviathan, in 1651.... The political theory that hobbes developed is based on three assumptions: (1) the existence of an original condition of "the state of nature," (2) the state is a man-made or artificial production, and (3) that the state is created by a social contract....
7 Pages (1750 words) Book Report/Review

The Movie Fight Club

(fight club 1999); when he mentions the growing relationship between Tyler and Marla; and when he talks about the destructiveness of Project Mayhem.... Take for instance the opening scene at the support centre for men with testicular cancer where Bob Paulson, weeping, chips in a question to the protagonist, 'Are we still men' (fight club 1999), while the protagonist/narrator's voice, is telling the story in the background.... Other longer dialogue scenes include when the narrator meets Tyler Durden, the time the fight club begins, and the scene in the bathroom where the narrator and Tyler have a talk....
3 Pages (750 words) Movie Review

The Characters Tyler and Jack in Fight Club and Calvin and Hobbes

This book review "the characters tyler and jack in fight club and calvin and hobbes " discusses Fight Club and the philosophies of John Calvin and Thomas Hobbes.... While Calvin is a boy focused on playing and doing the things a boy likes to do, his friend and stuffed tiger Hobbes are just along for the ride-much like tyler and jack in fight club.... The major link between the two will be demonstrated through the ethical and moral scruples of the cartoon calvin and hobbes....
6 Pages (1500 words) Book Report/Review

Emasculation in Fight Club

The second rule about fight club is you do not talk about fight club” (Palahniuk 25).... fight club by Chuck Palahniuk aims to portray the narrator as a person who is suffering.... jack learns that as a result of the testicular cancer, Bob has started to develop... However, things turn when he met tyler Durden during one of his flights.... The male characters in the book have become slaves to a world of consumerism....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Fight Club by Chuck Palahnuik

Based on the struggling daily life office worker who is desperate to change his life one way or the other by earning some money but ends up meeting someone, founding an underground fight club and actually changing his life and life's goals.... Setting, the two moved in now, start a fight club and during that time.... Based on the struggling daily life office worker who is desperate to change his life one way or the other by earning some money but ends up Suggestions in blue Khalid Qutaym Dr Pounds ENG 101 06/19 fight club fight club is a very well thought out movie and is based on a book of the same name by Chuck Palahnuik....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Close analysis to the film Fight club

Also, it will seek to provide a clear and concise analysis of the film's significance as it further interprets the film's meaning to the reader.... fight club does not disappoint and lives up to the expectation of the audience who are thrilled through the entire film.... cholars have identified fight club as a good example of conformity which is a concept that is determined by those around your circles (Wartenberg, 2012).... he film justifies the attempts of characters to move out of the violence that ensues during each and every encounter of the fight club because of the urge to break out of their roles that they have in the community to unleash their anger....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Dark Knight vs Fight Club

in fight club Tyler Durden is desperate to turn people from consumerism.... For instance, in fight club, Tyler Durden is desperate to change people in his society to stop consumerism and so goes on a rampage to bomb the icons of consumerism which in his own wisdom is the credit card companies; these he thinks are the ones that are forcing the people.... The same symbolic engagement can be seen in fight club.... The dark lighting in fight club also goes to match well with the theme of the movie....
6 Pages (1500 words) Movie Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us