StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Why did Antifederalists oppose Constitution - Admission/Application Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Their ideal type of government was like the one that existed under the Articles of Confederation. They wanted individuals and states…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Why did Antifederalists oppose Constitution
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Why did Antifederalists oppose Constitution"

The anti-federalists were a group of people that believed in having a federal government that was weaker than the individual governments. Their ideal type of government was like the one that existed under the Articles of Confederation. They wanted individuals and states to have the most power and the most control over what happened in the government. The national government should not be able to overrule the states. It should function as a way of providing essential services that the nation needed, like negotiating treaties and raising an army, but beyond a few vital functions, the federal government should be weak.

When the Constitution was drafted, anti-federalists resisted it. They wrote and gave speeches against the Constitution in their home states and urged people to vote against ratification. Patrick Henry and Samuel Adams were two of the most vocal anti-federalists. They were concerned that several provisions in the constitution would lead to a central government that could take away the rights of individuals and states. The first reason anti-federalists resisted ratification of the Constitution was the way the executive branch was established.

They viewed the office of President with skepticism. To the anti-federalists, this position looked too much like a monarchy. The patriots had just thrown off the chains of monarchy and anti-federalist’s did not want to reestablish anything that even resembled a monarchy. They feared that giving any one person power would result in abuses. The presidency as constituted in the executive branch looked like it had the potential to develop into a king. A second reason the anti-federalists opposed the Constitution was the idea of individualism.

Patrick Henry wanted the influence of local government and local individuals to stay strong. He was a strong believer in individual liberty and felt that the best way to maintain that liberty was to give local and state governments the most power. Centralization of power was a theme the anti-federalists wanted to fight in every possible way. A strong federal government was just a step away from tyranny, according to anti-federalist thought. They believed that there should be checks on power, and that the checks and balances in the Constitution that worked between the three branches of the federal government were insufficient.

The anti-federalists felt that the real check on the power of the federal government should be the state governments. A final reason the anti-federalists would not support the Constitution is the fact that it lacked guarantees for individual rights and privileges (Brands, 2011). They insisted on a Bill of Rights for the Constitution. This argument was the one that was strongest and resonated with the most people. The Anti-federalists wanted guarantees about certain rights such as freedom of religion and speech.

Federalists argued that the Constitution could not spell out every right that people should have. Still, the anti-federalists felt that some guarantees should be put in place. During the ratification process, many states agreed with the anti-federalists at this point, going so far as to make suggestions about what rights should be added after ratification. The Bill of Rights was added after the Constitution was ratified. This marked a partial victory for the anti-federalists. Work CitedBrands, H. W. American Stories: A History of the United States.

Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, 2011. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Why did Antifederalists oppose Constitution Admission/Application Essay”, n.d.)
Why did Antifederalists oppose Constitution Admission/Application Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1604304-why-did-antifederalists-oppose-constitution
(Why Did Antifederalists Oppose Constitution Admission/Application Essay)
Why Did Antifederalists Oppose Constitution Admission/Application Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1604304-why-did-antifederalists-oppose-constitution.
“Why Did Antifederalists Oppose Constitution Admission/Application Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1604304-why-did-antifederalists-oppose-constitution.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why did Antifederalists oppose Constitution

Article the First: The Federalist and Antifederalist Perspective

hellip; Although many of the constitutional amendments passes by the congress formed the bill of rights in the United States constitution, some were not very successful in the process.... This was especially so in the year 1789 on June 8 when one Virginia 5th District congressional representative agitated the congress to consider passing the Bill of Rights as part of the initial reforms to the constitution of the United States (Vile, 2010).... Article the First was a proposed amendment to the constitution of the United Sates whereby it sought to determine both the minimum and the maximum number of representatives at the US hose of Congress (Vile, 2012)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Colonists Experience with Governance

By design, when the constitution was ratified, the states were empowered.... Large numbers of antifederalists saw in the constitution a plot by the upper crust to steal power back from the common... The antifederalists, who opposed the stronger federal government, were arrayed against the federalists, who obviously favored it....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The constitution

A new plan… for the country had to be developed, and this was the federal constitution, which was drafted by a group of national leaders in Philadelphia in 1787, who then presented it to the whole public for consideration1. The articles of confederation were considered far too weak and of Essay Factors that led to the drafting of the constitution In 1780's America faced the critical period for their new nation.... A new plan for the country had to be developed, and this was the federal constitution, which was drafted by a group of national leaders in Philadelphia in 1787, who then presented it to the whole public for consideration1....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Should terrorist have miranda rights based on the constitution

However, terrorists simply cannot be extended the Miranda Rights because these are the people who aspire of the of the Concerned History and Political science February Should Terrorists have Miranda Rights based on the constitution?... Hence, the constitution should aptly respond to these peculiar circumstances by denying all democratic rights to the terrorists, including the Miranda Rights.... One major aspect of Miranda Rights is that the constitution does recognize the fact that there may be exceptional circumstances, posing a grave threat to public safety, where the extension of Miranda Rights to a suspect may not be pragmatic and safe....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The U.S. Constitution: A Global Perspective

Even about three decades ago, the United States constitution was still viewed as a model that other nations used as a… The influence of the U.... constitution became more intense in the 1970s.... This can be depicted by the manner in which many nations have altered their The Declining Influence of the United s constitution About two centuries ago, the United s constitution was written.... Even about three decades ago, the United States constitution was still viewed as a model that other nations used as a template to compose or update their constitutions....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Making of the United States

Therefore, the United States came up with the articles of confederation, which served as the first constitution.... Although ratified by the thirteen states the Articles were not sufficient, which led to the making of the United States constitution that would govern all the states.... However, Antifederalists opposed the ratification of the constitution.... They did not succeed as the constitution was ratified in 1789 and was established as supreme law....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Antifederalists: critics of the constitution

The thesis of the article centers on the voices of the Anti-federalists who felt the US constitution did not advocate for equal rights of both black and the whites during the creation of the federal system of governance.... In essence, Main has succeeded in showing that the The Anti-federalists: Critics of the constitution Question The thesis of the article centers on the voices of the Anti-federalists who felt the US constitution did not advocate for equal rights of both black and the whites during the creation of the federal system of governance....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Plato and Rousseaus Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown

… Plato, just like some of the great minds of his time, criticized democracy as part of the constitution, especially after the death of Socrates under democratic law.... Plato and Rousseau's Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown al Affiliation) Plato and Rousseau's Commentary on Constitutional Breakdown Plato, just like some of the great minds of his time, criticized democracy as part of the constitution, especially after the death of Socrates under democratic law....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us