StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

English Contract Law - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "English Contract Law" presents that offer and acceptance rules analysis are traditionally applied in contract law to determine the existence of an agreement between two parties. The agreement between the parties is comprised of an offer indicated by one person to another…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "English Contract Law"

The Application of Traditional Rules of Offer and Acceptance in English Contract Law in the Context of Standard Term Contracts and Electronic Communications Introduction Offer and acceptance rules analysis are traditionally applied in contract law determine the existence of an agreement between two parties. The agreement between the parties is comprised of an offer indicated by one person (“offeror”) to another (“offeree”). In this case, the offeror should be willing to engage in the contract on specific terms without negotiation. The existence of the contract starts once the offeree communicates the acceptance of the offer to the offeror. The formula of offer and acceptance was formulated in the nineteenth century and it is used to identify a formation moment when the parties agree on the same condition (Alpa et al, 54). Offer is referred to as an expression of desire to contract on specific terms which are made intentionally to become a binding after the person to whom it was addressed accepts it. It can also be defined as the statement of terms that the offeror is ready to be bound with. Acceptance requires that both parties should have engaged in conduct that manifests their assent in subjective perspective. The traditional approach that is applied in contract law is involves analyzing contract formation in terms of one party doing an offer and the other one accepting the offer. It has been argued by some scholars that not all contracts are analyzed in terms of offer and acceptance. They instead argue that one should focus on correspondence and the parties conduct as well as the parties’ terms of agreement Contracts which can not be analyzed in this perspective of offer and acceptance are said to be exceptional (Hedley, 230). Some critics have argued that the principles of offer and acceptance have a marginal relevance in business conduction. Different rules that are related to contract formation appear inform technical and schematic contract law. Practically, the law can adopt a fair and flexible pragmatic approach. Although most contracts are made using the offer and acceptance process, some agreements cannot be explained fully using the traditional approach. There are cases that may proof hard to reconcile using the traditional approach and they include contract not resulting from parties’ agreement. The court may imply a contract in the bases of public policy or on the bases of expediency which makes it difficult to analyze. Standard Term Context Generally contractual terms are settled using two methods that is by express negotiation and standard terms. English law when contrasted with other legal systems uses the analysis traditional offer and acceptance in cases of standard terms (Johnson, 342). In this context, there is the use of two types of rules in adjudication of the battle of forms. Battle of forms refers to situation where and placement of an order expresses standard terms of the supplier accepted on standard terms of the buyer. The first rule is the “last shot” rule which argues that incase of exchanged conflicting communications each is handled as a counter offer (Alpa et al, 399). Thus in this case the consequences of the contract are in form of final document of a series. The second rule is “knock out” rule which provides effect to the terms common to conditions of both parties. It does not depend on the matching acceptance of the offer and the acceptance. The first method of rule results to an all or no outcome at all. If there is an objective matching of offer and acceptance, the contract thus fully incorporates the terms and conditions. If perfect match does not exist then none of the set terms can be incorporated even if there exists similar terms between two proposal sets. The second method of knock out rule gives effect to the existing terms of agreement while ensuring that terms which are not agreed upon have not been incorporated. Though the knock out rule is largely applied in civil law systems, the English law promotes traditional last shot rule in offer and acceptance analysis. In analyzing standard terms used in the English law, there comes with it the potential that they will fully be incorporated but not diluted by negotiation. However they may not always incorporated (Gatt, 24). During the formation of the contract, both parties should be sure they are fully protected incase of any dispute. It is important to make sure that last shot has been fired before the contract is concluded. The supplier is always in a better position to gain this by using an acknowledgment which is properly worded accompanied by goods delivery. Buyers need to be cautious that they do not overlook the acknowledgement of orders referring to the terms of the supplier. They should not also accept goods which they have not verified that they match their terms and conditions. Electronic Communication The nature of common law and its foundations are deeply is deeply entrenched in meeting social evolution needs, such that the modern day sophisticated society finds justice as ancient society would have done. Rules of reasonableness as dictated by the common law adjudication assists the society to come to terms with all practical aspects of an issue such as use of electronic communication. The fact that use of electronic communication is an inevitable reality in the modern age makes common law the most applicable form of law to handle issues of contractual agreements. According to Hedley (246), UNCITRAL model offers a standardized reference from which communication in the modern age contracts can be approached. The author states that other forms of law such as legislation will be guided by the openness that the common law approaches electronic communication, citing the example of Irish legislation. Common law contract rules guiding the handling of electronic communication include fundamental clarifications such as consent among the parties, certainty of parties, subject matter certainty, price calculability as well as certainty of the consideration (Boss and Kilian, 34). In view of the above rules as given by the author, electronic communication as used in the law of contract must be clear of the necessary contract elements. Parties must demonstrate the presence of features that depict offer or acceptance as required in common law standards of a contractual agreement. General contract communication rules in common law provide that the contract will consider messages to be sent and received only in certain conditions. The location at which contractual communication takes place is usually a matter to be clarified in common law. The specific time that such communication took place is also important detail for verification. Issues of confirmation and feedback for such communication must also be clarified. Concerning a party’s response to communication advances from the other party, communication can be termed as synchronous or asynchronous with regard to the sender and recipient behavior (Hedley, 246). The author elaborates that the simultaneous reaction by the two parties must be demonstrated in order for communication to be considered in synchronous communication while asynchronous communication does not necessarily require the simultaneity concept. The traditional postal rule required parties to respond to such sent communication in a simultaneous manner where the content will be delivered. However, in electronic communication, asynchronous communication is favored. Besides the response from parties, sometimes customized links on the computer may be used to indicate acceptance to an offer on the electronic networks. There are several concepts that can be used to show willingness of a party to accept an offer. Clickwrap concept which involves clicking on some links to amount to an agreement, for instance clicking on “I agree” icons or “click here to agree” button amounts to communication in contract law. According to Hedley (248), without clicking such links, it is difficult for any party to demonstrate the acceptance of an offer. Likewise, the author states that it is difficult under common law to demonstrate the absence of a contractual communication of acceptance of an offer after clicking on the links. Apparently, many countries such as the United States, the UK and Ireland have entered into a legal regime that validates the applicability of this communication (Johnson, 339). While technicalities of the identity of the particular individual who effects the clicking exist, it is clear that the intention of communication of a contractual nature is already established (Gatt, 404). According to Gillies (144), the parties to a contract have access to the right of predictable jurisdiction regarding the nature of communication that electronic technology presents. The author uses judgments made by Lockerby and Rochlin where it was separately held that the communication concept contained in a contract must fulfill two conditions. One of the conditions is purposeful availment in the communication or contract while the other involves substantial justice. Due process dictates that the determination of communication in a contract must always offer justice to each of the contractual parties under common law. There are some tricky communication methods that appear to coerce parties to agree to contractual obligations. One of such communication methods include the browse-wrap agreement where entering a certain site is deemed to amount to acceptance of the terms of a contractual obligation posted by a certain party. The tricky part comes in because the browsing party finds it difficult to discern which sites are links to such contractual obligations (Hedley, 249). Usually, such sites amount to void contracts since it is difficult to determine the fundamental contractual concepts, but there are instances when clear link information contained in the page amounts to an agreement. Works Cited Alpa, G., Bar, C., Drobnig, U. & E.C The interaction of contract law and tort and property law in Europe: a comparative study. Munich, Germany: Sellier European Law Publishers, 2004. Print Barry, C. Conboy, K. Lang, M. Wojtkowski, G. & Wojtkowski, W. (eds) Information systems development: challenges in practice, theory and education. New York, NY: Springer Science + Business Media, LLC, 2009. Print Boss, A.H. & Kilian, W. eds. The United Nations Convention [etc], Kluwer Law International, October 2008:530) Bruner, S. P. Briefcase on contract law. Portland, OR: Routledge, 2004. Print Gatt, A. “Electronic Commerce- Click-wrap Agreements.” Computer Law and Security Report 18, 2002. Print. Gillies, L. E. Electronic commerce and international private law: study of electronic consumer contracts. Hampshire, England: Ashgate Publishing, Ltd, 2008. Print Hedley, Steve, The law of electronic commerce and the internet in the UK and Ireland. London, UK: Routledge, 2006. Print Johnson, P. “All Wrapped Up? A Review of the Enforceability of Shrink-Wrap and Click-Wrap Licenses in the United Kingdom and the United States.” European Intellectual Property Review, 25(2003):338-344 Lehr, W. & Pupillo, L. M. Cyber policy and economics in an internet age. Norwell, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2002. Print U. N United Nations Convention on the use of electronic communications in international contracts. United Nations Publications, 2007. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(English Contract Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words, n.d.)
English Contract Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words. https://studentshare.org/law/1575965-critically-discuss-the-application-of-traditional-rules-of-offer-and-acceptance-in-english-contract-law-in-the-context-of-i-standard-term-contracts-and-ii-electronic-communications
(English Contract Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words)
English Contract Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1575965-critically-discuss-the-application-of-traditional-rules-of-offer-and-acceptance-in-english-contract-law-in-the-context-of-i-standard-term-contracts-and-ii-electronic-communications.
“English Contract Law Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words”. https://studentshare.org/law/1575965-critically-discuss-the-application-of-traditional-rules-of-offer-and-acceptance-in-english-contract-law-in-the-context-of-i-standard-term-contracts-and-ii-electronic-communications.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF English Contract Law

Consideration as the Badge of Enforceability for a Contract in English Law

However, while this aspect is a principal requirement in the English Contract Law, there are further assessments that might be made; in spite of the mere fact that consideration really existed in the contractual agreement, which then nullifies the agreement as unenforceable.... Therefore, while consideration forms a fundamental building block as far as the English Contract Law is concerned, it has emerged that it is not indispensable, and thus there are circumstances under which the courts can regard a contractual agreement that did not entail consideration to be legally binding, while also nullifying a contractual agreement that involved consideration as unenforceable in law (Gillies, 1988 p....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Implied Terms and Sales of Goods

The basic principles of English Contract Law are the right to freedom of contract within the law and the basic need for some kind of certainty.... But one who trades with a few countries only, or is about to make a big deal, will sometimes try to obtain information on the foreign contract law or law that come into question.... In the countries of the European Union where the trade has increased many times since the Common Market was established, unification of the contract law will become more urgent the more the trade grows....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

English Contract Law - Walford v Miles

The aim of the work is to try to identify the key contract law case in the English Contract Law in the 20th century.... hellip; Miles and its meaning is in revisiting the principles of good faith in the English Contract Law. It is stated, that connection of the legal rights and good faith principles have always been a problem for English Contract Law (Feinman, 1983) and a word for an English businessman has always been his bond in any business relationships....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

English Contract Law

The buyer (the individual or organization who buys or agrees to buy the Goods from the Seller) has the option to appeal this case in English court of law because in any contract (a promise or set of promises which the law will enforce (Pollock, 1952)) made between two persons or… parties even though it is mainly intended to provide for stream lining and convenient mechanism of transaction but is governed ultimately by English Contract Law.... The case can be filed against the seller as it violated both English Contract Law and unfair contract terms act (1977)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Contract Law and the Civil Justice System

This research essay will investigate how various… provisions of English contract laws are interpreted to the favour of rich individuals and big companies and also stress the need to revamp the century-old contract laws. The English Contract Law remains unfair and this can be demonstrated in the case of pre-incorporation Pre-incorporation contracts are those contracts which are entered by the founders of a company before its existence or before its incorporation.... The legal status of the pre-incorporation contracts under English common law is that it is illegal and cannot be approved or ratified or adopted the advantages of the contract which has been entered into on its behalf before its incorporation....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

The Concept of English Contract Law

om in connection to the counter claim of payment of £650,000 for contract value price less the costs assigned to task (V) that was not completed and a further £100,000 in damages for wrongful termination from completing the work.... hellip; The paper will also seek to establish whether there was wrongful termination or not according to the provisions of the contract and whether Lastly, this paper will establish whether is a liability on the part of A.... According to the agreement the contract was to be performed by 1 September, 2013....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Damages Awards in Law of Contract

In the United Kingdom, contracts and agreements are governed by a body of law called the English Contract Law.... In contract law, the injured party has to prove that the damages suffered directly arise from the breach.... This law is regulating contracts across England and Wales.... This law is widely shared by… It should be that this law is experiencing gradual changes due to the UK's membership of EU and other international organizations like Unidroit....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Analysis of Law of Contract Cases

Samson, Diana, and Maggie are under contractual obligations to buy computers from Abdul according to the English Contract Law.... The English Contract Law clearly mentions that the buyer and seller have to bind themselves to the terms and conditions mentioned at the time of the notice or contract and the persons violating the same may be punished under the legal system (Bradney et al.... Had they agreed to purchase, Abdul also would be considered to bind to the contract law provisions for selling his computer according to the terms and conditions mentioned in the notice placed in the University notice board....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us