StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Constitutional Question of Cruel and Unusual Punishment and the Death Penalty - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Constitutional Question of Cruel and Unusual Punishment and the Death Penalty" shows although the Supreme Court does not regard the death penalty as a form of “cruel and unusual” punishment, its manner of imposition may bring the case within the ambit of the 8th Amendment clause…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.3% of users find it useful
Constitutional Question of Cruel and Unusual Punishment and the Death Penalty
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Constitutional Question of Cruel and Unusual Punishment and the Death Penalty"

Download file to see previous pages

The question as to whether the death penalty is a ‘cruel and unusual punishment” within the context of the 8th Amendment is often the underpinning issue of many cases appealed to the US Supreme Court by appellants who were convicted and sentenced to death by the trial courts. The clause “cruel and unusual punishment” first appeared in the 1686 English Bill of Rights and was adopted by the Commonwealth of Virginia Declaration of Rights. Its inclusion in the federal Bill of Rights was proposed by James Madison, who himself hailed from Virginia.

Although it was successfully incorporated into the 8th Amendment, its exact meaning was not clearly explained nor its relevance in the American setting fully understood. Under English law, the clause was meant to limit the English courts from imposing punishments that were too barbaric and cruel as was the practice of courts during the reign of the House of Stuart. Punishments such as drawing and quartering, boiling the convicts alive, or crushing them with heavy objects were just some of the barbaric punishments that the English Courts in the Stuart era employed.

In the American setting, the “cruel and unusual punishment” clause was not much of an issue prior to the 20th century considering that the barbaric practices of the early English courts were unheard of. The modes of execution in the US include hanging, firing squad, gassing, electric chair, and just recently, lethal injection. Although some of these modes of execution are more painful than others, they are not considered barbaric and cruel punishments.Scrutiny of US case law on the matter reveals that the death penalty is not a “cruel and unusual punishment” within the 8th Amendment context, and yet, sometimes it is.

The Court has declared that it does not per se infringe upon the 8th Amendment, and yet has also ruled in some cases that its imposition is “cruel and unusual” punishment. It depends on the circumstances of the case and perhaps, the perspective of the Court at the time a death penalty case is being heard. The first time that the clause was made ground in an appeal was not a death penalty case, but it was nevertheless, significant because it was the first time the US SC expanded the meaning of the clause to cover legislative acts as well as declared that punishment not in proportion to the crime is “cruel and unusual.

" This was the Weems v US case in 1917, where the appellant, a disbursing officer in the Philippines, then a US territory, was convicted of falsifying public documents. He was sentenced to suffer 15 years of hard labor in prison in chains as well as imposed civil and political disabilities. He contended that this was “cruel and unusual punishment” because it was disproportionate to the crime he committed. The Court agreed. It was, however, in the latter part of the 20th century that the US SC had to contend with several challenges from various death penalty cases that invoked “cruel and unusual punishment” to nullify the death penalty sentences handed down in the trial courts.

This sudden enthusiasm was perhaps spurred by the surge of abolitionist movements around the world which saw more than 60 countries outlawing their death penalty laws from the 1960s to the end of the 20th century.

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“The Constitutional question of cruel and unusual punishment and the Research Paper - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1426583-the-constitutional-question-of-cruel-and-unusual
(The Constitutional Question of Cruel and Unusual Punishment and the Research Paper - 1)
https://studentshare.org/other/1426583-the-constitutional-question-of-cruel-and-unusual.
“The Constitutional Question of Cruel and Unusual Punishment and the Research Paper - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1426583-the-constitutional-question-of-cruel-and-unusual.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Constitutional Question of Cruel and Unusual Punishment and the Death Penalty

Capital Punishment, a Life and Death Issue

Utilizing the death penalty is considered by some to be the most heinous and obvious instance of cruel and unusual punishment.... Taken together in the phrase, 'prohibiting cruel and unusual punishment' signifies that the penalty should be apportioned equitably according to the specific offence committed.... The paper "Capital Punishment, a Life and Death Issue" underlines that the death penalty does not deter crime.... This amendment is frequently invoked when speaking of the legal merits regarding the death penalty....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

The Death Penalty Punishment

Utilizing the death penalty is considered by some to be the most heinous and obvious instance of cruel and unusual punishment.... Taken together in the phrase, 'prohibiting cruel and unusual punishment' signifies that the penalty should be apportioned equitably according to the specific offense committed.... This essay "the death penalty Punishment" discusses the moral and legal concerns that literally are a life and death issue and is a key barometer when measuring a culture's collective conscience....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Eight Amendment of the U.S. Constitution - Freedom from Cruel and unusual Punishment

According to the Eight Amendment, the law preventing the implementation of cruel and unusual punishment was enforced to eliminate prior methods of punishments classified as cruel and unusual.... For example, impalement was form of cruel and unusual punishment becauese the punishers should pierce the person's body with a long killing tool.... Other forms of cruel and unusual punishment included drawing and quartering, embowelling alive, public dissecting, beheading, and burning alive [Wilkerson V....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Does capital punishment equate to cruel and unusual punishment

Capital Punishment as a cruel and unusual punishment The controversies regarding capital punishments in the United States assumed newer dimensions with the Eighth amendment that guarded the citizens against cruel and unusual punishment.... However, the question whether capital punishment equates to "cruel and unusual punishment?... Capital Punishment as a cruel and unusual punishment The controversies regarding capital punishments in the United s assumed newer dimensions with the Eighth amendment that guarded the citizens against cruel and unusual punishment....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Critique Based on American Judiciary Laws

In a five to four decision the court decided that the death penalty ruling did constitute to cruel and unusual punishment and thus violated the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendment.... Georgia raised an important question of law on whether the imposition and carrying out capital punishment in that particular case and two others constituted cruel and unusual punishment.... William Furman was the main figure in the above mentioned case that led to the United States Supreme Court outlawing the use of the death penalty in most cases....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Canon Law & 8th Amendment

Bill of Rights, prohibits excessive bail or fines, as well as cruel and unusual punishment.... Canon Law is the body of officially established rules governing the faith and practice of the members of a Christian church.... Any church's or religion's laws, rules, and regulations; more commonly, the written policies that guide the administration and religious ceremonies of the Roman Catholic Church is the Canon Law. ...
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Dehumanizing Effects of Long Confinements before Execution

In examining the statement “the death penalty, when preceded by long confinement and administered bureaucratically, dehumanises both the agents and recipients of this punishment and amounts.... ven as death penalty is to be applied quite sparingly, with special reasons Debates on retention or abolition of the capital punishment have predominantly existed for years causing some countries to consider prolonged delays that precede execution, mostly allowing the condemned person reasonable time to appeal3....
18 Pages (4500 words) Essay

The Federal Criminal Justice System: the Tight of Freedom From Cruel and Unusual Punishment

According to the Eighth Amendment, the law preventing the implementation of cruel and unusual punishment was enforced to eliminate prior methods of punishments classified as cruel and unusual.... For example, impalement was a form of cruel and unusual punishment because the punishers should pierce the person's body with a long killing tool.... Other forms of cruel and unusual punishment included drawing and quartering, embowelling alive, public dissecting, beheading, and burning alive [Wilkerson V....
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us