StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the report “Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor” the author discusses the essay of Garrett Hardin, who argues against any “system of worldwide food sharing”. His purpose is to demonstrate the adverse effects of the proposed World Food Bank on population growth…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.8% of users find it useful
Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor"

Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the PoorIn his 1974 essay, Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor, Garrett Hardin argues against any “system of worldwide food sharing” (482). His purpose is to demonstrate the adverse effects of the proposed World Food Bank on population growth and the resulting pressure on resources. Hardin criticizes the ‘spaceship metaphor’ which seeks to assert that every individual on earth has an equal right to an equal share of the available resources.

He claims that the ‘lifeboat metaphor,’ with its emphasis on limited capacity, and necessary adherence to the margin of safety, more accurately depicts the situation. He identifies the unchecked population growth in poor nations as the greatest threat to the earth’s dwindling resources. Hardin draws attention to what he terms “the tragedy of the commons,” according to which the absence of central control will result in any common resource being ruined because “the right of each to use it may not be matched by a corresponding responsibility to protect it” (480).

He equates the World Food Bank with a commons, arguing that this would encourage incompetent governments to ignore setting aside emergency food reserves. He denounces foreign aid in any form, asserting that saving life results in the destruction of the environment and lowers the quality of life.The information presented by Hardin, as far as population growth goes, is not based on hard facts, except for the USA. Talking about population increase in developing countries, he says, “Let us imagine another 210 million people increasing at the rate of 3.

3 percent a year” (Hardin, 479). Obviously, this is only an educated guess on his part. In the same way, Hardin says “Most likely the rate of population increase will decline much faster in the US than it will in the other countries” (480). Again, this is conjecture on his part: even if it is a reasonable conjecture. However, Hardin’s assertion that the population will continue to increase is indisputable and it is clear that the ‘lifeboat’ cannot accommodate everyone. Hardin’s ‘commons’ argument is very well thought out and is based on realistic, logical reasoning.

I cannot but agree with Hardin’s strong indictment of unchecked population growth. The lifeboat analogy is particularly appropriate and graphically demonstrates that the survival of humanity itself depends on curbing population. It cannot be denied that the earth’s resources are being depleted at an alarming rate. However, Hardin’s rigid stand against all forms of aid to poorer countries is difficult to condone. He acknowledges that we live in “a world that must solve real and pressing problems of overpopulation and hunger” (479).

Hardin’s essay appears to propose only one solution: let crop failure and famine periodically kill large segments of the poor in order to conserve natural resources for the welfare of the surviving rich. Hardin succeeds in convincing the reader that the proposed World Food Bank would possibly encourage irresponsible nations to use it as a free meal. Hardin’s criticism of population growth is also very valid. However, his only counter-proposal is the complete halt of any form of aid to poor countries.

Hardin could have strengthened his argument by suggesting some alternative strategies to combat population growth. Perhaps access to the World Food Bank could be conditional, depending on proof of measures implemented to control population. A weakness in Hardin’s argument is its assumption that rich countries can be isolated from the poor. In the present age of interconnectedness, this is unrealistic. Hardin himself acknowledges this in his warning that the members of the lifeboat must constantly guard against boarders.

The major weakness in the passage is its lack of humanitarianism. If Hardin’s argument is carried to its logical conclusion, extending the life span of the elderly, or vaccinating babies is also not advisable. Works Cited.Hardin, Garrett. (1974). “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor.” Title of Collection. Ed. Editor's Name(s). City of Publication: Publisher, Year. 478-483. Print.Outline.In his 1974 essay, Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor, Garrett Hardin argues against any “system of worldwide food sharing” (482).

His purpose is to counter the proposal to set up a World Food Bank. He identifies the unchecked population growth in poor nations as the greatest threat to the earth’s dwindling resources. Hardin’s criticism of population growth is very valid. However, his suggestion to check population growth by denying aid to poor countries in times of calamity is difficult to accept. Hardin fails to give any alternative, constructive suggestions to solve the problem of hunger and overpopulation.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/social-science/1617786-writing-an-essay-analyzing-the-argument-of-garret-hardin-scan-material-will-be-attached
(Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor Essay)
https://studentshare.org/social-science/1617786-writing-an-essay-analyzing-the-argument-of-garret-hardin-scan-material-will-be-attached.
“Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1617786-writing-an-essay-analyzing-the-argument-of-garret-hardin-scan-material-will-be-attached.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Garrett Hardin: The Case Against Helping the Poor

Food Safety; Pests and Vectors; Air Quality

In this case, the workers Environmental Health and Safety  Environmental Health and Safety  Evidently, a mandatory food safety training requirement for all restaurant employees will be much better than a stronger enforcement program by the local health department.... In this case, the workers follow the safety directions only because there is close supervision by the authorities over them, and if they are found responsible, there will be punishment....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

The role of the IMF in helping poor and debt-troubled countries

Generally, the organization lives by three key objective, first, “keeping track of the global economy and the economies of member countries,” second, “lending to countries with… The different opinions toward the IMF indicate that there are problems and issues that must be addressed considering the major role it has in the global economy. Countries suffer Certain occurrences such as post-war rehabilitation or various crises could lead to a situation where a country would have minimal resources to support the running of its government....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

The role of the IMF in helping poor and debt-troubled countries

The main goal of International Monetary Fund is to ensure there is regional integration and cohesion by bridging The role of the IMF in helping poor and debt-countries Instructor Course Institution DateInternational monetary Fund is an organization that aids in fast-tracking payment systems and circulation of currencies among financial institutions and countries globally....
2 Pages (500 words) Case Study

Corporate Social Responsibility and Wal-Mart

Wal-Mart's case It is apparent that the approach that was taken by the management of Wal-Mart to compensate the families of 112 people that perished in an accidental fire cannot bring back their lives; however, taking this issue into business perspectives, it possess various benefits to the company....
1 Pages (250 words) Case Study

Hedging Equity

Through the use of Another advantage of using options is its ability to allow the trader to sell them against shares that he or she already owns.... In this case, the investor can use them even to protect his downside.... Options also enable one to employ considerable leverage....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

The Welfare of the Poor

Some people may ask what they could get in return for helping the poor.... The paper 'The Welfare of the poor' presents Mother Teresa of Calcutta, a famous missionary for the welfare of the poor who once said 'love one another; help one another; be kind to one another'.... However, programs for the poor are not that widespread and accessible.... Institutions for the poor are not allowed to be easily established....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Factors Involved in Understanding Helping Behavior

the case study "Factors Involved in Understanding Helping Behavior" states that Helping others is a generally acclaimed virtue, as confirmed by the premise of kindness and altruism for the welfare and benefit of others contained in the sacred doctrines of various religions all over the world.... hellip; What we have is proofs of a helping continuity that, most probably, is altruistically arbitrated since when we examine one at a time the descriptive power of key egoistic options, helping stays grand....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Hearing Problems and Deafness

The author of the following paper under the title 'Hearing Problems and Deafness' gives detailed information about the most important counseling issues that relate to your pupils/students/clients (and their families) – regarding Hearing Problems and Deafness.... hellip; Hearing impairment is one of the problems that have a massive emotional as well as psychological effect both on the family as a whole and the child as an individual....
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us