StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Gun control - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name: Subject: Instructor: Date: Gun Control: The Ethical Justification of Possessing Firearms The term gun control is at times understood as a counterpoint to the idea of gun rights, where the former is used to refer to the implementation of strict regulations and policies pertaining to firearm possession, while the latter refers to the position that upholds the presumably inherent right to possess firearms…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.4% of users find it useful
Gun control
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Gun control"

Download file to see previous pages

The two sides of the debate showcase significant arguments. On one hand, it is argued that the ownership of firearms is a fundamental right, while on the other it is argued that there is no such fundamental right. Various studies and surveys on the effectiveness, as well as the ineffectiveness, of restrictions have been conducted, only to end inconclusively. A fairly recent survey by the Open Society Institute (2000) merely ranks the states of America based on the degree of toughness of their gun laws.

The study states: The most striking results of this survey are a) the lack of uniformity in firearm regulation across the country; b) the enormous differential between the top and bottom of the spectrum; and c) the poor scores achieved by most states (Gun Control in the United States, 2000). These results demonstrate the difficulty and the highly varied attitudes toward gun control, despite arguments appealing to fundamental rights, and empirical data. Perhaps a philosophical examination will provide a sufficient ground for such arguments, particularly from the vantage point of ethical theories.

The author attempts to provide an ethical justification for gun control by taking a look at two ethical frameworks: deontological or Kantian ethics, and utilitarian ethics. Ethical Justifications Pertaining to Gun Control: An Analysis As mentioned above, arguments both in favor and against gun control rely on fundamental principles to justify their positions, as well as on empirical, albeit inconclusive studies. But at its base, the issue is one that pertains to restrictions. Hence, if the claims are to be analyzed, it can be said that the propositions: a) “There should be strict and standardized restrictions on gun ownership,” b) “There should not be strict and standardized restrictions on gun ownership.

” are both evaluative claims, supportable by properly examined moral or ethical principles, and perceived beneficial consequences. The first proposition draws its strength primarily from the premise that there is no such basic right as to own a gun. The proposition is further supported by the claim that self-defense by way of gun use is counterproductive, since some studies seemed to show that domestic violence is in fact increased as a result of the presence of firearms. The second proposition takes its strength from the premise that there is a fundamental right to own a gun, as stated in the Second Amendment.

To push for strict regulation of gun ownership is to infringe on that basic right. It further strengthens its argument by claiming the exact opposite of the first proposition’s claim, that crime incidents are in fact lessened as a result of the presence of guns. In short, the two propositions both give statistics to support their claims. However, the author believes that a potential beneficial consequence must only be highly probable to sufficiently support the claim. From the perspective of Kantian ethics (“Metaphysic of Morals,” 1898), it might be argued that the insistence on having the right to own guns is grounded on the fundamental moral duty of self-preservation.

If this idea of self-preservation is extended to accommodate acquiring the means for the latter, then gun ownership is justifiable. An act that is done out of duty has moral weight, as opposed to one that is done only out of conformity to duty

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Gun control Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1397010-gun-control
(Gun Control Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/sociology/1397010-gun-control.
“Gun Control Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1397010-gun-control.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Gun control

Gun Control-Argumentative Paper

Name: Course: Instructor: Date: Gun control-Argumentative Paper The gun debate in the United States has a long history, with many people arguing for and against Gun control in the same measure (Spitzer 35).... The two most important legislations that touch on the issue of Gun control are the National Firearms Act that was passed in 1934 and the 1968 Gun control Act.... The Gun control Act prohibits the sale of firearms between states, mail-order sale of firearms, transfer of firearms to minors and establishes strict licensing requirements for dealers, manufacturers and importers of firearms....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Argumentative Evaluation: Gun Control

Name of the of the Concerned Professor English 16 October 2011 Gun control The article, A Clamor for Gun Limits, but Few Expect Real Changes by Adam Nogourney and Jennifer Steinhauer, published in The New York Times on 13 January 2011, revolves around the issue of Gun control in the aftermath of the Tucson shooting.... In the argumentative structure chosen by the authors, the writers seem to be well aware of the fact that in the aftermath of the Tucson shooting, there exists a predominant pubic sentient around the issue of Gun control....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Against gun control

Analysts are recurrently debating over the subject on how to limit the use of guns or how to effectively implement Gun control so that the increasing rate of crime and violence can be reduced (Myers).... Thesis Gun control is a significant need of today's world in order to protect and safeguard humanity.... Therefore the present strategies related to Gun control do not seem much beneficial and neither have they shown any decrease in the rate of crimes....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Gun- Control Debate

The Gun control Debate The Gun control debate in the United States has become a messy subject in the recent years.... Politicians and statesmen argued that weak Gun control will have calamitous consequences.... The proponents of Gun control point out to the consequences of lax measures, whereas the opponents of Gun control point to the constitutional right of possessing arms and ammunition.... The goal of this author is to convince the audience that the Gun control debate is unfair and corrupt....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Gun control policymaking

The 1990s have been an active period in Gun control policymaking, in the United States.... Gun control Policymaking The 1990s have been an active period in Gun control policymaking, in the United s.... Local governments continued to enact Gun control laws, but increasing numbers of states passed laws preempting local action and in a few cases even repealing local laws.... This report seeks to analyze the unique position and solutions on issues pertaining Gun control in the United States....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Gun Control/ Argumentative paper against Gun Control

However, by the 1990s, the homicide rate in the of the of the of the Gun control Introduction Thesis ment: Gun control laws cannot prevent or reduce the crime rate.... he various interventions made in the US to implement Gun control measures, in order to reduce crime have proved to be unsuccessful.... Third, the federal Gun control Act of 1968 imposed stringent restrictions on the possession and bearing of firearms, throughout the US (Preface to "Deterring Gun Violence")....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Gun Control Debate

This essay provides arguments from both sides regarding Gun control and concludes as to which side has a convincing and stronger argument.... On the author's view, the opponents of the Gun control laws have stronger arguments in comparison to their counterparts … But on the other hand, it is necessary that some control is also established on the sales of these guns because minimized Gun control laws would give an opportunity to all the individuals to buy a gun i....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Gun Control Laws

Doeden, "Gun control " written by J.... Lott, and  "Guns, Gun control, and Elections" written by H.... Wilson… A distinguishing factor of this book is that the author has presented the legal aspect of Gun control laws by carefully choosing different cases that are important in addressing the Gun control dilemma.... Also, another factor of the book is that Spitzer has used actual legal documents to explain the various cases There are various statistics given in the book which help in comparing the severity of Gun control in the United States with other states....
6 Pages (1500 words) Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us