StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Human Condition as Seen Through Art Work - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Human Condition as Seen Through Art Work" discusses that “La Comedia Illumina Firenze” by Domenico di Michelino and “Abelard and His Pupil, Heloise” by Edmund Leighton might not seem to have much in common upon initial viewing, but an examination of themes shows similarities…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
The Human Condition as Seen Through Art Work
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Human Condition as Seen Through Art Work"

The Human Condition as Seen Through Art Work Much about the human condition can be discerned through the examination of art work. Though one might at first be hesitant to exclaim that a painting portraying an imagined version of hell, purgatory, and heaven says much directly about the real world, further examination of these types of work show this to not be true. In examining the two paintings “La Comedia Illumina Firenze” by Domenico di Michelino and “Abelard and His Pupil, Heloise” by Edmund Leighton, the theme of life-affirmation can be drawn from both of these works. The two paintings might not seem to have much in common upon initial viewing, but an examination of themes and motifs in both of these works shows similarities. The purpose of this paper is to artistically explore and analyze two separate art works in order to utilize artistic application to better understand the element of humanity within each. Michelino was an Italian painter from the Florentine school. He was also a close follower of Fra Angelico. In the dome of Florence’s church of Santa Maria del Fiore, one can find his most famous piece of work known as The Comedy Illuminating Florence or The Divine Comedy. Virtually all of Michelino’s works were based on Biblical tales and stories. This particular piece depicts purgatory, hell, paradise on earth (the Garden of Eden where Adam and Eve lived) and the earthly spheres. Michelino took the name of his teacher and used it as his own. This particular work is specific more to understanding the almost otherworldliness which Dante’s writings contained. This writing was then translated into numerous forms of medium and are still assimilated with religion today. Understanding the premise for Dante’s views allows the observer to discern more detail and meaning in the recreation of Dante’s world done by Michelino. The piece can very much be seen as a product of its time, considering that the Heavenly Spheres upon which the planets were supposedly thought to rest are depicted at the top of the painting. Considering that this aspect of the scientific thought of the times was reflected in the work, it is not a difficult stretch to state that the religious views of the time are also reflected in the work. Take for example the depiction of the demons in the picture: “They too are designed in the conventional manner, with their usual bestial features, horns, fangs, bat-like wings…claws, tails, hideously grinning mouths, huge ears, etc.” (Altrocchi 39). Hell and its creatures are depicted as terrible, cruel, and monstrous, none of which of course actually come from biblical sources. In fact, the modern conception of hell as being a place of torture and fire all come from Dante. Considering the time period during which the Inferno was composed, it is easy to discern why this was done, and then this reason merely needs to be transferred to Michelino’s painting as sort of merely an update of ideas found in Dante. The lives of people during Dante’s era were filled with dread and death, especially considering the bouts of plague that the city of Florence had to deal with during Dante’s time. If life was so terrible and dangerous, then it was assumed that there had to be some sort of reward for actually dealing with all of this strife. When viewed in this context, we can see how the message of the painting, as well as the poem, can be viewed as life-affirming. It seems to be saying that though there might be suffering in one’s life, if one follows the word of God then that person will be rewarded with paradise and an everlasting existence. It was quite necessary for any sort of religious-based works to be life affirming, considering that the life of the average citizen of Florence was less than desirable. While the depiction of hell and purgatory might not initially appear life affirming, there are ways in which depictions of such places can be. Michelino’s depiction of Dante’s work shows that he was attempting to visually recreate the poem as possible: “That Michelino, in painting Purgatory, read very carefully Dante’s Purgatorio, is especially manifest in the second circle, that of the envious” (Altrocchi 45). In Dante’s conception, characters such as Aristotle were given the least harsh treatment in Hell first and foremost because Dante respected them so much. Of course, real-life figures are not the only figures in The Divine Comedy: “The vast majority of characters from and allusions to classical mythology in the Divine Comedy derive form the works of Virgil and of these writers, primarily Ovid and Lucan” (Ruffa14). Other characters did not receive such an easy time, such as merely being envious. For this Dante relegated them to Purgatory, and Michelino followed suit. Not reaching Paradise for just being envious seems harsh and not life-affirming, but there is another way to view it. If these characters had not been envious, then they would have reached Paradise. This is stating that every life is good and is worth enough on its own so that Paradise can be reached. By being envious of others, one is losing sight of the worth that one’s own life has. By forcing people to value their own lives by punishing them for being envious, the work takes on a very life-affirming aspect to it. Paradise in and of itself should be considered a life-affirming quality to the work itself. As Dante as the narrator of the poem was easily able to traverse hell and purgatory with angelic help, this gives the readers hope and affirms that it is not too difficult to live one’s life in such a way that heaven is attained. Dante himself is depicted hovering at the very forefront of the painting holding a book. Whether this is his own work or the bible, it seems apparent that it is meant to be the guide through the dangers presented in the piece so one may attain Paradise. If this is the case, then the piece is very life-affirming, as it seems to be attempting to show people how to reach heaven. Even with all the depictions of demons and people suffering in hell and purgatory, overall the poem and the painting as an extension of the poem is very much life-affiming Leighton was the son of an artist by the name of Charles Blair Leighton. Edmund was born in London and was known in his adult years for his extremely skillful craftsmanship. The central medium of use was paint and he mainly focused on works depicting regency and medieval subjects. His particular piece known as “Abelard and His Pupil, Heloise” depicts a taboo encounter between an instructor and his pupil. The painting shows a beautiful Heloise leaning slightly into the left side of her seated master Abelard. The body language is the indicator of the manner of their relationship. This particular love story is said to be the saddest love story to ever be told. By understanding this love affair and who these individuals were, one can better grasp and appreciate the artistic rendering of them by Leighton. Though the story behind the piece is thought to be the saddest love story ever, the fact that these two people were in love can be taken as life-affirming in the first place. Above all else, perhaps it is love that should be considered to be what makes life worth living, and seeing as these two, though separated, had a love that endured all sorts of hardships, that alone should be considered life-affirming. There is much to be interpreted from the painting itself. First, the position the two are in should be noted. While the initial relationship between these two was of student and teacher, we can see from the painting how this relationship has changed. The teacher is a person that is in a superior position in relation to the student, but in this painting Abelard is kneeling next to Heloise; their relationship has changed to the point where Abelard feels comfortable putting himself in an inferior position in relation to Heloise. This sort of reversal in relationships should be considered life-affirming as the relationship between student and teacher has been so ingrained into society as to seem unchangeable; the love between Abelard and Heloise is so strong as to reverse a societal convention. Also to be considered is the expressions on their faces. Abelard’s expression is of great concern. It is obvious that they are beginning to experience some of the hardships that are to come. Heloise’s expression almost seems blank even as Abelard gently holds her hand. As love is the most life-affirming attribute of human existence, it also follows that the loss of that would be the most tragic event that could happen. Though Abelard and Heloise are eventually separated physically, they end up keeping up a correspondence through letters, and it is the record of these letters that lets us know that though separated physically, they could not be separated from their emotions. The two are outside at a bench with a book open. It is obvious that this was supposed to have been a lesson, but what is going on between them is obviously more powerful than the pursuit of knowledge. Their love is so strong, in fact, that it will lead the to risk their careers and their future in order to be together. It should be considered that Abelard was one of the most important thinkers of his time, yet for years to come after his death he was almost exclusively known for his love for Heloise: “Great as was the influence exerted by Abelard on the minds of his contemporaries and the course of medieval thought, he has been little known in modern times but for his connexion with Heloise” (Snell). From this we can learn that all people in general view love or the pursuit of love as a more important endeavor than the pursuit of knowledge, and as this painting, though at the same time portraying a tragedy, also affirms that life is worth living since love exists. Though both of these pieces are life-affirming, they are very different in the ways that they are life-affirming. Michelino’s piece depicts a life that must be suffered through in order to reach paradise, which in this world view is what all of a person’s life is really about. This is not to detract from a person’s actual life that is being lived on earth; this is merely the case considering the quality of life that most people had during the time that the original poem was written. It is saying that the inherent worth is there the whole time, though it can only be properly enjoyed at the end of one’s life. Leighton’s painting came from a different era, one in which it was acceptable to value one’s life while still on earth. It is only through this sort of world view that the sacrifices that Abelard and Heloise made would have been acceptable and would not have resulting in either person finding themselves in wither a circle of hell or a level or purgatory. The worth of life is always apparent and not merely inherent and waiting as potential between Abelard and Heloise. The way in which they are similar is in the way that both paintings portray seemingly harsh or negative realities (suffering through purgatory for being envious or being separated from a loved one), yet they still, upon close examination, show that life truly is worth living. They both remind us that there are hardships that must be suffered through, but I don’t think that anyone would say that Abelard regretted his actions as he has been remembered for having such an intense love for another person. Works Cited Altrocchi, Rudolph, “Michelino’s Dante.” Speculum, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 15-59. Raffa, Guy P. Dante World: A Reader’s Guide to the Inferno. Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 2007. Snell, Melissa. “Peter Abelard: Article from the 1911 Encyclopedia.” The New York Times, 2008. Available from Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Human Condition as Seen Through Art Work Coursework, n.d.)
The Human Condition as Seen Through Art Work Coursework. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1715849-you-can-choose-a-topic-i-trust-your-judgment-abelard-meets-heloisedante-and-the-three-kingdoms
(The Human Condition As Seen Through Art Work Coursework)
The Human Condition As Seen Through Art Work Coursework. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1715849-you-can-choose-a-topic-i-trust-your-judgment-abelard-meets-heloisedante-and-the-three-kingdoms.
“The Human Condition As Seen Through Art Work Coursework”. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1715849-you-can-choose-a-topic-i-trust-your-judgment-abelard-meets-heloisedante-and-the-three-kingdoms.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Human Condition as Seen Through Art Work

The Human Condition in Poet's Obligation by Pablo Neruda

The paper tells that the human condition is one that is often placed in perspective, specifically with the demands and expectations in society and culture.... hellip; In the poem by Pablo Neruda, “Poet's Obligation,” there is an understanding of the human condition and lack of freedom that is associated with the lifestyles which many live.... nbsp; The argument which he creates is one which is based on the difference between the human condition and the inability to have a true sense of freedom within the world....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

Summaries of Psychology Research Studies

In the group condition, it was found out that men increased their spending following a win, thus allowing for the hypothesis that these patterns reflect a male bias to calibrate their level of in-group investment.... human non-independent mate choice: is model female attractiveness everything It is in human nature for them to have the urge to mate.... Psychologists have been exploring human behavior in regards to mating and the factors that influence the choices made by individuals concerning their mating partner....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Newspaper report on the conditions in the factories and mining areas of Industrial England

Further, it is through bad ventilation and overcrowding that characterizes these areas, that the level of deaths and illnesses have continuously increased, while the productivity of the workforce in the industries and the factories continue to decline, considering that they can no longer perform at their best, due to health complications (Chadwick, 2).... While affecting the health of the workers adversely, the horrific atmosphere and the lack of clean air for breathing takes a toll on the workers, through reducing their energies, and consequently their level of performance (Engels, 1)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Humans Are Sinful

Although human beings appear pure when they are born, the seed of sin has been buried inside their mind for generations.... However, these norms do not always present themselves in their entire lifetime because they are developed over a period.... The society has been highlighted as the leading contribution to predict the… God creates individuals with a pure heart and they pick the evidence of evil after the interaction with the members within the society....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Main Characteristics and History Air Conditioning Creating

The water that evaporated from the reeds cooled the air that blew through the window into the house.... Ancient Romans on their part circulated water drawn from aqueducts through building walls to keep the buildings cool.... hroughout human history, several attempts have been made to avoid the discomfort that comes with a lot of heat....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

The Human Narrative Art: The Human Condition and Understanding

A paper "The Human Narrative Art: the human condition and Understanding" claims that different artistic works have since been noted to portray the elements of sorry.... Such information may not be portrayed in the same way and style of representation It is worth noting that different painter in history displayed their work communicating sorrows in the society (Bednarik 92).... Vilhelm Hammershoi was a Danish painter who started his artwork in 1883, but it is noted that as he continued his work, he was fond of repeating some elements of his work....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Issues in Practicing Social Work with Adults

"Issues in Practicing Social work with Adults" paper gives a critical analysis and discussion of the various issues which arise within social care for patients with dementia with due consideration of the diversity and the related differences among patients.... 15) say that condition is also characterized by a gradual loss of personality and intellectual capacity.... This diversity is in form of the differences among patients in terms of age, gender, ethnicity, physical and mental condition, social-cultural affiliation, economic status, beliefs, and values (Webb, 2009, p....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework

In What Conditions People More Enjoy Lives

One has to work towards knowing himself or herself in those three areas.... Hard work without play makes Jack a dull boy this proverb should make should be applied to those people who overwork themselves.... It requires one to work hard to maintain them.... ere are the conditions that one has to meet in order to achieve an enjoyable life: One needs to work on emotional well-being which is a fundamental thing towards achieving an enjoyable life....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us